Skip to main content
Feb 11, 2021 12:29 AM UTC
Archived

Prevent Feature failure when changing an Extrude direction which uses PROJECT command

Related products:Creo Parametric

Ticket Reference: 15668428

SPR Reference: 11556077

 

We have an Extrude that references the edge of a quilt by using the PROJECT command in sketcher.

When we flip the direction of the quilt and then flip the extrude the feature fails. If we do an edit definition of the sketch in the Extrude and then click OK, it works again!

 

PTC R&D says this is a 'limitation of the software'. 😭

The official word is:

“The limitation is that the edges formed a counter-clockwise loop at the time of creation. So now when they go clockwise the software considers this inside-out contour and changes the material side of the extrude. The software does not recompute the orientation to preserve the user intent.”

 

Please fix.

 

Thank you!

14 replies

Apr 1, 2021 3:39 PM UTC

Hi there again,

 

1 - The extrude as a qulit generates failures is it not as a result of changing the extrude direction? I was suggesting in the UDF to not ever change extrude direction. Generate an extrude with the "Symetric" option, to extrude in BOTH directions always. Then, if you want to sunk / engrave the letters, use the quilt to remove materials with the solidify remove material. If you want them raised, use the same quilt to solidify add material. In the UDF you can create a family table to exclude some features. Create two rows, one for the cuts, supress the second solidy, another row in the family table, to add material, and supress the first solidy, leaving the second solidify that adds material. Hope this helps.

 

2 - The second suggestion, which would take much more time, is to suggest to PTC for future versions of Creo that there should be added an option to add the option to parametricaly scale quilts or bodies. See this idea request I just made:

 

https://community.ptc.com/t5/Creo-Parametric-Ideas/General-transformation-tool-including-scale/idi-p/722290#M14168

 

 

 

jwaghAuthor
Apr 1, 2021 3:46 PM UTC

Thanks for your suggestions. I voted on your idea. I'll have to play around with your suggestion for #1. Theoretically, we would want one value to govern both directions you suggest below. This would require testing. Now that we've converted to subscription licensing, I may want to play around with some of the flexible modeling features and see how well it contorts/shrinks/grows the geometry/quilts. 

Community Manager
Feb 20, 2025 11:07 AM UTC
Status changed to: Acknowledged

Hello,

Thank you for your idea. Based on the details and popularity of your idea, we are acknowledging it as the Community management team. This is not a commitment from the Product team.

olivierlp
Community Manager
Apr 1, 2025 3:59 PM UTC
Status changed to: Archived

Hello,

We are archiving your idea as part of a general review. This action is based on the age of your idea and the total number of votes received, as per this announcement.

You can always post a new idea with all the details required in the form.

Thank you for your participation.

Olivier