Skip to main content
Sep 25, 2023 7:47 AM UTC
Acknowledged

MBD - 2D Detailing - future vision

Related products:Creo Parametric

Please include detailed documentation such as screenshots, images or video.

1. What product and version are you running?
Creo Parametrics, 8.0.4.0


2. What is the problem?
Missing options to define links and relations between: Saved Orientation / Annotation Plane / Combination State, and force Annotations more automated to take on definitions without loosing them again.

 

Currently I'm working out a MBD Process (or try to do so) for our RD&E team.

The aim is, that all Annotations are created in 3D by deriving dimensions from 3D features and enhance them by additional Annotations e.g. GTOL, text, Symbols and so on.

All this is proper sorted in Combination States, using Sections if necessary, or datum planes in case the Annotations need a specific offset from the geometry. 

The intension (my future vison) is, that the Combination States shall represent the views in 3D and they shall be used in 2D drafting to create the views there (because this will remain a mayor requirement of the method). This without doing additional work on. Not only because we are lazy people, but as well because between 3D and 2D no difference shall exist.

 

Such a method finally should not cause a bigger effort than doing it "conventionally" as, leave the method free to the Engineers to do the drawings as they like, creating the drawings mainly in 2D drafting.

 

What I'm looking for to get closer to "future vision", I'm trying to describe it here.

If the Pre-condition is like:

  • a Combination State N is activated

 

The behavior as desired:

  • Per definition assigned Annotation Plane N becomes automatically active
  • Per definition assigned Saved Orientation N becomes automatically active
  • The assigned Annotation Plane (Plane or Face) should become visible and/or highlighted.

 

If now a dimension is derived via "Show Annotation" or features are added as" text", "geometrical tolerances", "datum features", "datum targets", "surface symbols" or any "symbol" is inserted or if any Annotation is "Assigned to State" it should automatically get the (or let's say a), pre-set size (scale), oriented according the assigned "Saved Orientation" N, be placed on the assigned "Annotation Plane".

 

Any Annotation assigned to Combination States with per definition assigned Annotation Plane and Saved Orientation should receive the definitions of "Plane" and "Orientation", unless a manually modification is done.

 

If an Annotation is added by "Assign to State", the user shall be informed that the annotation is moved and no more available on the previously assigned state. In case the user needs to show a dimension on more time e.g. on an second Combination State he shall be forced to create it manually.

 


3. Are you using a workaround? If yes, please describe it.
Doing all the work manually:

each time first selecting the annotation plane, than selecting the Combination State, than derive dimension from features, moving them to a offset plane, applying them the Saved Orientation, sort the Annotations manually to get a proper layout.

4. What is the use case for your organization? Describe how your idea would work in context or how it would apply to a practical situation.
In first step:

The drawing will remain the document which will be referenced to. It will be part of contracts (supplier or customer).

The 3D views shall be internally used for viewers in the Windchill data base or ERP System and for people involved in the manufacturing process to avoid the opening of the 3D data in Creo. The printout of drawings shall be avoided. 

 

In second step:

The MBD shall be used for NC programming.

5. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization? (Number of users affected, hours of lost productivity, etc.)
We currently maintain about 30 creo licenses, some of them are globally.

The effect affects all the defining work, to bring the MBD proper to the right annotation plane with a matching orientation and size of the text and symbols.

In addition, I read many ideas or questions in this forum describing parts of this "future vision" so the effect might be multiplied many times.

Finally, if the effort remains the same, such methods will not be accepted by the users and may have no chance to establish in the company(s) and MBD remains a future vision.

1 reply

Sep 25, 2023 8:03 AM UTC
Status changed to: Acknowledged

Hi @Pius!

Thank you for your idea. Based on the information you provided, we are acknowledging it as the Community management team. This is not a commitment from the Product team. Other users may comment and vote your idea up.