Skip to main content
Mar 5, 2021 12:20 AM UTC
Acknowledged

Include a useable modern font (TrueType/OpenType) compliant with ASME Y14.2 Standard

Related products:Creo Parametric

The purpose is to switch from the ProE font.ndx/stroked stick font to a modern font.  This helps with:

  • WYSIWYG Exporting while maintaining real searchable/editable text...especially for PDFs
  • Creo4 essentially disabled font thickness control (except for entire notes) while the new Bold feature doesn't visibly bold for the stroked font styles.
  • General downstream reuse is impaired by using a stroked font instead of a modern universal font.

 

It should at least have the following features/compatibility:

According to the standard, it should be:

  • All caps with exceptions
  • Gothic/Sanserif (without flourishes)
  • Single stroke (all letters are the same thickness everywhere in the letter)

 

To be useable it should also be:

  • Monospaced (spaces and letters take up the same space)...this is essential for readability for text alignment and tables on Engineering drawings)
  • Comprehensively changed and controllable with config options
    • MBD compatible (ideally updateable with dwg config or mapkey-able from drawing)
    • Symbol compatible (diameter, degree, etc)
    • Whatever font is used it should be either universally present or embedded.  Not a big problem for Creo because startup scripts can distribute, so this is mainly for other applications (Creo View, pdf, dxf, etc).
  • Nice to haves
    • Ideally, this font should be especially easily legable with All Caps but also lower case.
    • 100% differentiable between letters and numbers (e.g. Il1 = iL1, etc)
    • A text style checkbox like in word to switch between sentence case, title case, all caps, Small caps)

 

Great discussion on this:

 

Please comment if I may have missed anything.

19 replies

May 25, 2022 11:14 AM UTC

@LawrenceS I think he is implying that a lot of customers modify the default font or are using a TTF. There are threads in the community on how to go in and manually change the number "1" to have a hook at the top. I can't immediately find it but somewhere in the community is a post from someone that attached a modified version of the font.ndx that fixed the 1 issue.

May 25, 2022 12:05 PM UTC

Are TrueType fonts supposed to allow their aspect ratio to be modified?  I was under the impression that they are designed to be scaled but not stretched or squished.  PTC seems to be claiming the same thing:  https://www.ptc.com/en/support/article/CS99844

May 25, 2022 2:01 PM UTC

@TomU,

 

The quote 'This is because TTF fonts are "graphic" fonts; no parameter driving thickness and width does exist' from the linked support case doesn't agree with the testing that has been done in this thread, at least in regards to font "width". As proven above, Creo has the ability to output variable font widths to PDF. They can somehow do it with the ArialMT true type font used for converting from stroked to TTF.

 

While ArialMT is a good looking font I don't feel it's the greatest technical drawing font. I'd much rather have converted text be a monospaced font that closely matches font.ndx. The only exception is I'd want all the characters to be unique, which is major failing of font.ndx. If one doesn't exist PTC should have it commissioned.

 

I've been monitoring ability to output PDF's with TTF's for over a decade and honestly this situation is lackluster (trying to use my "nice" words here). For the cost of this software and the additional cost of maintenance most of us pay they need to do better. When creating a PDF with TrueType fonts became an option it should have come with a better default font.

 

I simply can't accept "It can't be done" when it's already being done.

LawrenceSAuthor
May 25, 2022 3:13 PM UTC

@Chris3, I didn't realize either was so popular.  Thanks for the clarifications.

 

@TomU, I saw a similar article yesterday in the knowledgebase and sent PTC a correction.  TTF and OTF can be variable width controlled.  According to our Marketing website guru who works a lot with fonts, controlling the width is a feature for all modern fonts and he was very surprised Creo didn't recognize this functionality.  But even better, we can see this working in MS Word with apparently any TTFs or OTFs that can be stretched/squished to our heart's content! 

LawrenceS_0-1653490365028.png

 

You can also see in the Windows font directory that there are usually various width fonts saved in the TTF or OTF files.  e.g.

LawrenceS_1-1653490628281.png

However, even the fonts that only have one TTF file (such as the randomly selected Britannic Bold which only has one TTF file shown in the Windows Font directory) Word still controls the width using the above points to make narrower or wider.

LawrenceS_2-1653490839990.png

LawrenceS_3-1653490930369.png

 

May 25, 2022 3:25 PM UTC

@LawrenceS,

What you're seeing in Word is not the same thing.  This is just adjusting the distance between each character, it's not actually changing the shape (or aspect ratio) of the characters.  Notice how the 'O' doesn't change shape:

TomU_0-1653492278426.png

 

LawrenceSAuthor
May 25, 2022 6:06 PM UTC

@TomU, Looks like you are right! Thank you

 

Looking at it again, there is another setting above it called scaling that does appear to stretch and skew as we want:

 LawrenceS_0-1653498554181.png

Because it actually looked taller when I scaled the text larger, I put a normal O as the first character to prove to myself that it was actually the same height! 😀

May 25, 2022 6:12 PM UTC

Yep, scaling does indeed change the aspect ratio.  I even tested with Arial WGL which is PTC's own custom version of Arial and that scales just fine too.  I guess if Microsoft is capable of stretching and compressing the TrueType fonts in Word, then PTC should be able to do the same in Creo!

TomU_0-1653502285698.png

 

LawrenceSAuthor
May 25, 2022 6:46 PM UTC

👍👍👍😎

Community Manager
Feb 12, 2025 10:51 AM UTC
Status changed to: Acknowledged

Hello,

Thank you for your idea. Based on the details and popularity of your idea, we are acknowledging it as the Community management team. This is not a commitment from the Product team.