Skip to main content
Jun 28, 2024 9:28 PM UTC
Archived

Improvements to Standard Hole notes in Creo Parametric

Related products:Creo Parametric

1. Describe the Problem

1) Add the option to not show the current implementation of the automatically created hole note. When the hole note is automatically created the annotation is part of the 3D annotation set.   

This has been previously request by others, but remains an issue.

02-25-2016: https://community.ptc.com/t5/Creo-Parametric-Ideas/The-option-add-note-unchecked-by-default/idi-p/463129

05-25-2022: https://www.ptc.com/en/support/article/CS159462

2) Provide enhanced methods for hole identification. 

2A) For instance instead of a separate hole note, can the hole details instead be pushed into the drilled hole dimension.    I often either do this manually or the feature is provided by GDT advisor.

2B) Could the standard note tool provide a UI to create industry standard callouts by selection box.  I know there is some capability to setup specific type notes in the hole tables, but the number of options to setup is cumbersome in the current hole table implementation. 


2. Are you using a workaround?
Ignoring the note, or manually deleting the note. Create new notes or dimensions with required detail.

3. What is the use case for your organization?
Proper hole dimensioning is critical in the 2D and 3D environments. Currently its time consuming and repetitive to properly setup all hole callouts.

4. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization?
Creates extra work to remove the automatic hole note.

3 replies

Jun 30, 2024 7:25 AM UTC
Status changed to: Clarification Needed

Hi @N.Barnes 

Assuming that it would be possible to populate the hole details into the hole's dimension (instead of creating the note), how would you want this to work for multi-element holes like a counter bore/counter sink, thread etc. ? 

This is an essential aspect for MBD workflows.

 

In other words, when you have a multi-element hole you typically shows its dimensions in one of the following 2 ways:

1. You have a dedicated dimension annotation for each of the dimensions of the multi-element hole (drill diameter, depth, counter bore diameter etc.)

  • In this case, each of the holes elements are described by the individual dimensions, such that the corresponding semantic references are collected for each of the dimensions. For this method, what would be your expectations from the hole note? Is it even required for this method?

2. You have a combined annotation for the hole, which will describe all the dimensions that are included in the multi-element hole and thread.

Since this is a single annotation, it can collect semantic references for the entire hole and all the included surfaces, but since it is a flat list of references (not a hierarchy or a structure) how will the receiving consumer of this MBD data will be able to differentiate between the surfaces of the hole that belong to the drill diameter and between those that belong to the depth or the counterbore dimensions ? 

  • In this case, to which of the hole's surfaces, should the combined note be attached to? 

PS - I believe that the same aspects are currently being discussed in the ASME MBE committee, but I don't think that they have a final definition for those cases. Anyhow it would be interesting to get your POV on the multi-element case.

 

Best Regards,

Michael Fridman

Creo Product Management

Jul 2, 2024 6:45 PM UTC

The no not creation when creating standard holes is a useful feature. We don't do MBD, we only detail standard holes in 2D drawings.

Community Manager
Jul 16, 2024 11:20 AM UTC
Status changed to: Archived

Hello,


We are following up on our request for additional information on your idea. In the absence of further comments from you, we are archiving your idea. You still have the option to post a new idea with all the details required.


Thank you,

Catalina

Community Moderator