Skip to main content
Jun 26, 2020 11:03 AM UTC
Acknowledged

Improve the weld module

Related products:Creo Parametric

Below a list of problems I ran into when using the weld module. I will update this list when I find more.

 

  1. It's not possible to flip weld annotations in 3D, only in 2D. So when using MDB it looks ugly (PTC case)
  2. The tail of the annotation stays on even if you turn off the sequence ID and the note (PTC case).
  3. Creating a sold weld is nice because you can use it in Simulate. But when you create welds in a way you also get weld annotations that can be used you ran into the problem that the welds interferere in the corners and therefore simulate can't mesh. Putting it into one set solves the issue in Simulate but then the welds are not houw they are placed in the real world and therefore the weld annotations are incorrect.
  4. Creating a double weld with unequal lengths gives an incorrect weld length in the annotation. Because it simply sums up the weld length and divide by 2. So a weld which has a length of 50 on one side and 40 on the other gives a weld annotation stating that the weld length is 45 on both sides.(PTC case).
  5. It's not easy to adjust the number of decimal places. Probably something you didn't notice when using ANSI or live in the US but quite annoying when there is 30.000 stated where it could be just 30 (and it also should actually be 30,000 but that's another discussion). To change this by default you have to actually change the weld annotation. And if you have ever tried that you know how hard that is (I've done it) and how much work it is. There is a config.pro opting called weld_dec_places but I cannot find what this setting does.
  6. Updating weld standards is almost impossible.
  7. Using a centralized place for your customized weld annotations is not possible.
  8. Adaptive weld annotations should be nice so you doesn't have a weld annotation that has a line that is WAY to long for the text that it uses.
  9. Not possible to exclude/disable features from assembly Simplified Representation (see article and Product Idea )
  10. The number of fatal errors is really high when using solid welds (see for one example case)

12 replies

RobertHAuthor
Jul 13, 2022 6:40 AM UTC

Not seen 8 or 9 so can't tell but as seen from the past I would not count on big changes.

 

In 7.0.5.0 there is also an annoying bug (SPR 13389840) with solid welds. When you use solid welds in a model and that model is in an assembly, each time you do an edit definition action on some of the models in the subassembly (so not on the model with the solid welds), the model with solid weld is marked as modified. This bug is fixed in 7.0.8.0.

Community Manager
Feb 12, 2025 9:55 AM UTC
Status changed to: Acknowledged

Hello,

Thank you for your idea. Based on the details and popularity of your idea, we are acknowledging it as the Community management team. This is not a commitment from the Product team.