Skip to main content
Oct 10, 2024 1:53 PM UTC
Acknowledged

IMPROVE THE MIRROR FEATURE (REAPPLY MIRROR WITH THE FULLY DEPENDENT OPTION)

Related products:Creo Parametric

1. Describe the Problem

When creating mirrored copies of selected features, the following regeneration options are available to manage the dependency between the original features and their mirrored copies:

  • Partially dependent - Dimensions and AE Details only (default) : only the dimensions and annotation element details of the copied features are dependent on the original features;
  • Fully dependent with options to vary : all the elements of the copied features are fully dependent on the original features or geometry.

Until Creo Parametric 5, I have always suggested using the Fully dependent option (not default) because it allows modifying the options of the original features and changing the references in the sketcher.

 

In fact, with the default Partially dependent option, attempting to add references to the original feature section will trigger this message, as such modifications are not allowed:

fferlito_0-1728566743127.png

Starting from Creo Parametric 5, by editing the definition of a Mirror feature is available the following button:

fferlito_1-1728566815182.png

Clicking  fferlito_2-1728566856446.png Reapply Mirror, the Mirror items collector return available allowing the addition/removal of features... fantastic! ... but it only works with the Partially dependent option!

 

With the Fully dependent option, when editing the Mirror feature, the Reapply Mirror button is greyed out and the items collector is no longer available.

fferlito_3-1728566856447.png

 

The following table summarizes the possibilities:

 

ALLOWS EDITING ORIGINAL

FEATURE OPTIONS

ALLOWS ADDING/REMOVING FEATURES

Partially dependent

NO

YES

Fully dependent

YES

NO

(Change this)

 

I propose to make the Reapply Mirror button available for the Fully dependent Mirror Feature.


2. Are you using a workaround?
No, I have to choose every time which option to use, assuming that there will be something I cannot modify in both cases. It's quite a dilemma...

3. What is the use case for your organization?
All the users I’ve encountered during training sessions wish they could mirror features with the advantages of the Fully Dependent option, while still having the flexibility to add or remove features later

4. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization?
Most users do not know how to manage these cases and either avoid the mirror feature or use it incorrectly. With this improvement, the mirror feature will be effectively usable.

2 replies

Community Manager
Oct 10, 2024 2:47 PM UTC
Status changed to: Acknowledged

Thank you @fferlito for your idea. Based on the information you provided, we are acknowledging it as the Community management team. This is not a commitment from the Product team. Other users may comment and vote your idea up.

Mar 11, 2025 10:31 AM UTC

This issue should be finally solved for good. It is unbelievable stupid functionality concerning only Creo, there is nothing compared in any other CAD system available. It should be possible to add or delete references in any time or in any phase user is working and if it violates for example the mirror feature then it should be notified to user when updating the model not being refusing the action user wants to do. This is totally unacceptable that PTC has refused to fix this non-functionality since Creo version 1.