Improve the Extrude to make it more robust to design changes
- 1 reply
- 18 views
1. Describe the Problem
When creating solids and surfaces with an extrusion, the default depth setting is "Variable".
When cutting solids or surfaces with an extrusion, we have the possibility to select "Through all" to avoid having to change dimensions if the solid or surface we want to cut is enlarged. This guarantees resiliance to design changes.
But when creating solids or surfaces, the same resiliance does not exist. We might want to create another body to use as a tool to cut an existing body. Or create an extruded surface to cut a solid. Since we only are allowed to specify a distance or specify a datum plane as reference, it forces us to create those datum planes even for common use cases.
a) The idea is to provide another extrude option when adding material to replace the non-working option of "Through all" that only workds for cuts. This option could be called "Beyond" and it would allow the extrusion to be made up-to the extents of a selectable reference, which could be a body, a quilt, or a surface..
If the user does not select a reference and is extruding a surface, the extents would go beyond the bounding box of the active body.
b) When adding the "Beyond" option the UI would automatically provide a field to specify an offset beyond the limits of the bouiding box of the referenced geometry. DEfault offset would be zero. This would avoid having to make another click in another checkbox to specify the offset value that exists for regular "Up To Reference".
c) Would work for both sides.
2. Are you using a workaround?
There are two workarounds: a) Use "Variablle" and specify a distance, visually provide a bigger value, and hope for the design to not change, since it could fail with a Creo error, or fail silently. b) Use "To Reference" and waste additional time creating parallel planes referenced to the maximum of the referenced geometry. Time consuming when trying to create up-to references and referencing cylindrical surfaces, since the planes have to be tangent to the geometr, and in other cases, it might be difficult to determine the extents of the geometry. c) Waste additional time creating a "Enclusere Volume" or "boduding box" for the selected geometry, orient the box paralell to the future sketch plane, make the bouding box create quilt geometry, and finally create the Extrude feature and select "To reference" to reference the maximum (or minunum or both) of the bouding box.
3. What is the use case for your organization?
Making design both more efficient and more robust for a very common design pattern.
4. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization?
Wasted time and frustration to have to use any of the workarounds.
Status changed to: Archived 2026-07-06
We are archiving this idea as part of a general review. This action is based on the age of your idea and the total number of votes received, as per this announcement.
You can always post a new idea with all the details required in the form.
Thank you for your participation.
