Hole Export Control for ECAD IDF (EMN) and IDX Standards to account for holes that are in 'parts'
Please include detailed documentation such as screenshots, images or video.
1. What product and version are you running?
Creo 9.0.7.0
2. What is the problem?
We are aggressively attempting to use the ECAD MCAD Collaboration Standards (IDF and IDX) but are running into some stumbling blocks, especially with holes. There are many holes in the board, like a standoff hole, that is already included in our decal/cell of the standoff within the ECAD tool (PADS, Xpedition). So when the standoff is in their layout tool, it automatically places the hole. Which means, they don't want the EMN file we send them to include another hole. The PCB team would need to search through the import and manually delete the holes each time! It gets even weirder. The PCB team uses parts for regular mounting holes as well! Even if there is no actual part, they create one with a simple hole. This helps for routing within the schematic and other reporting metrics as well. I believe there is a convoluted way to make this work by assigning a feature level parameter (ECAD_ASSOCIATED_PART) to each hole that matches the reference designator of the part and then the ecad tool might ignore it... This is something that won't end up happening and might not even work in all situations (Sketched Holes). It also introduces a big risk where the wrong reference designator is entered or updated. The point of the collaboration process is to save time and issues. By adding this large amount of work, goes against the whole idea and the team will just end up sending out the collaboration files with the holes that don't have this parameter. If there was some way to either exclude holes from the export altogether, or figure out another simpler, smarter solution to this problem, that would be great!
3. Are you using a workaround? If yes, please describe it.
No. We are struggling to get thru these roadblocks.
4. What is the use case for your organization? Describe how your idea would work in context or how it would apply to a practical situation.
Our organization is built of producing products that have PCBs. Most of our engineering effort revolves around PCB development. Therefore creating processes that optimize this is critical. Ideally, the collaboration file that the PCB team imports from the Mechanical Team won't have holes listed for any parts that are using that hole (standoffs, connectors or even mounting hole parts).
5. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization? (Number of users affected, hours of lost productivity, etc.)
This impacts about 100 users. It would easily reduce the collaboration time and errors between the two teams as this is one of the big pain points from having us continue with the collaboration effort.
