Skip to main content
Jun 19, 2023 2:27 PM UTC
Acknowledged

Enable a new part to use an existing *.prt or *.asm for its material & merge its geometry to start

Related products:Creo Parametric

Please include detailed documentation such as screenshots, images or video.

1. What version of the software are you running?
8.01


2. What is the problem?
I would like to use an existing part/assembly as the material for a new part file and at the same time have CREO import the files geometry as if using the merge feature and have the first item in the new part's browser be that file. Further detail; to start a new part I would like the ability to select an existing file as the start part/template file. Along with this, if an existing part is selected, as suggested, I would like CREO to recognize this referenced part/assembly as the new part's material with option to utilize the materials library as is. For example if an existing part is allowed as the template/start part it would be beneficial for CREO to automatically default the material parameter to no material needed.

3. Are you using a workaround? If yes, please describe it.
No, there is no work around. It is possible to use the merge feature to reference the part needed, but CREO/Windchill cannot push the merged part as the material to GEMS. This must be manually added to the EBOM.

4. What is the use case for your organization? Describe how your idea would work in context or how it would apply to a practical situation.

 

Well, there are three scenarios where time could be greatly cut down if the function I described above could be implemented.

  • Process drawing sets: Forging, Rough-out, Machining which each successive step using the part prior.
  • Weldment process drawing similar to No. 1. (Prep/Weld/Machining)
  • Modification drawings, where an existing inventory item needs to be modified by some process (machining/welding, etc.).

I also believe as should you that this ability would impact your entire install base as the other prominent CAD system have had at least partial ability as I’ve described above. For instance, the derive component feature in Autodesk Inventor works in just this way.


5. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization? (Number of users affected, hours of lost productivity, etc.)

Here at SLB I’m told we have an install base of 1300+ users, which is spread among several subsidiary entities. Hours saved? Annually perhaps in the thousands companywide if the majority of users have just a couple instances like the ones I described above. When you consider how long it would take now to create a merge and then must manually create a reference in GEMs to represent the material for a simple part that’s under a re-work scenario. I also believe as should you that this ability would impact your entire install base as the other prominent CAD system have had at least partial ability as I’ve described above. For instance, the derive component feature in Autodesk Inventor works in just this way.

6 replies

Jun 19, 2023 2:43 PM UTC
Status changed to: Acknowledged

Hi @TC_10043994!

Thank you for your idea. Based on the information you provided, we are acknowledging it as the Community management team. This is not a commitment from the Product team. Other users may comment and vote your idea up.

Jun 19, 2023 2:54 PM UTC

Hi, @achirila 

 

Thank you for the quick reply and consideration! Have a great day.

 

Tim C

Jun 19, 2023 3:21 PM UTC

What is "GEMS" and how does it pertain to Creo Parametric? It's not a phrase or acronym I am familiar with.

Jun 19, 2023 3:41 PM UTC

hey @StephenW . It's the PLM system we use in my division. Global Enterprise Management System I believe is what it stands for. There are many popular systems used globally, like SAP for example (our other divisions use SAP), but we happen to use Windchill to communicate CREO info to GEMs. So, whatever can be defined by CREO (geometry, materials, relations, parameters, referenced specification docs) needs to end up in GEMs associated properly on the BOM/parts list. This relationship btw CAD and PLM system is one of the reasons I suggested the ability discussed in my suggestion.

Jun 20, 2023 5:53 PM UTC

I agree that there are situations where we could and should use templates with solid geometry. We could achieve this by making a normal empty part using an empty geometry template file, and then making an external inherited feature to derive from an existing part. But since this workflow is so common, it takes extra-time for the extra-step. For instance, many "standard parts" that we use on the mold industry have to be machined and cut, but to efficiently use a "standard part". or "off the shelf part", we theoretically should create those standard parts using a family table. (For screws for instance). Nut the problem is that some of the standard parts we use, unlike screws, need to be cut, or machined, so, we have to add in context cuts to those standard parts. If we use directly a family table instance, we would be "polluting" the original family table part with extra features for each project where we use a "machined"  or "cut" standard part. So, for each aplication of a standard part, we would have to make an inheritance feature from a family table part instance to decouple the modiifications from the library standard part, which is cumbersome and time consuming for a very commonly used worflow. If we could derive a new part from an existing (library or family table) part directly, it would speed up the process a lot.

Jun 20, 2023 6:39 PM UTC

Thanks again for the replies all. Hopefully, there will be many more to come. To add another point to the workflow/function of what I'm requesting, if the CREO developers can just find a way to add the function of being able to select an existing part/assembly to "import" its geometry even if the material selection exercise cannot be avoided, this will conform to the examples I mentioned above under question 4. Example; you start a part like regular with a blank template and set up the materials etc. Then, the first thing you want to see in the browser is a glyph representing that existing prt/asm, so to do this, whether it be a "start/import body" button or whatever you select it then choose the item to be referenced. Viola, part referenced, geometry imported....now you can proceed forward with your weld/machining process/re-work, The ability to reference an existing entity at the part level and having CREO/Windchill/GEMS understand this relationship would be highly valuable. As the newer versions of CREO can utilize the multibody feature the next logical step to me would be to get these bodies (referenced or modeled) through the "body" feature. BUt hey I'm just a goofy caveman, so what do I know. 😉 Hopefully, this will begin some good conversations to motivate the powers that be. CREO is a really powerful program, I'm just surprised it didn't have this ability many versions prior. Thanks again everyone!!!