Skip to main content
Jul 13, 2015 10:59 PM UTC
Acknowledged

Creo needs a modeled thread option

Related products:Creo Parametric

Up until a couple years ago, modeled threads were a serious taboo in CAD.  They were unnecessary, used processor power and bogged down large models.

With the rise in 3D printing though, there is a definite need for modeled threads and Creo is awful at doing it.  The helical sweep feature is so klunky, unintuitive and onerous to use, and result is an unfinished thread with no options for lead in or thread end.

PTC please make an easy to use thread option for Creo that incorporates all of the nuances of threading operations.

27 replies

Jun 26, 2012 12:00 AM UTC

1st of all, I would love to have "actual threads" rather than the just the cosmetics.  If we have it already, someone please tell me where it is, and tell me I don't have to create them from scratch.  I've had great luck using larger actual threads in STL rapid prototyping.  Its overdue, PTC

2nd: The formatting of the Thread Note is insufficient.  We are bound to having a space after a parameter (second bullet below).  This is archaic and needs a better "end parameter name" delimiter in note annotations. 

We all have "standards" in thread call-outs (okay, many of us) and, although a great attempt, the PTC version lacks consistency with many current standards.  Forcing a space at the end of a parameter just doesn't let you do what needs to be done.

I tried to use the very common "4X" on a number of instances and all I could do is "4 X"  The same is true for the depth symbol and controlling the number of zeros on the depth callout. 

I remember the old days when these still used the dimension parameter that could be seen with the "Switch Symbols" button.  We cannot even do this any more that I can see.

I know I haven't researched this a lot (hey, I'm a newbee!) and I really shouldn't have to work this hard to make a good related thread callout per "our" standards, not PTC's.  Here we go back to kludging the callout for threads.

PLEASE... work a little harder on making these parameter a little more friendly to use in drawings.

Thanks

Formatting_thread_callout.JPG

Jun 26, 2012 2:49 PM UTC

While I wouldn't agree to actual threads on each hole, I would love the have the option. Threads on a large assembly with many threaded holes can kill a CPU!

Oct 29, 2015 10:22 AM UTC

Excellent idea, long overdue

In addition to use when working in 3D for reviewing, designing etc... the current method "Cosmetic thread" is really only for 2D drawing. As a consequence when looking at the 3D model one cannot tell if there is a thread or not without looking at the 2D drawing, which defeat the object.

While Autodesk does not provide a solution of the above idea, at least it is possible to see in 3D there is a thread. See screenshot attached. In addition, this feature in Inventor is recognized in 2D as being a thread. It is nothing than an envelop of an image (which changes depending on the type of thread) but it does help a lot when viewing 3D models. In Creo, this is flat, no possibility to see if the holes are threaded or not without actually creating the feature in 3D which takes time, increase the file size a lot etc...

Inventor Thread representation in 3D.PNG

Mar 27, 2023 2:01 PM UTC

Hello,

 

This idea has been merged with another idea from @TomD.inPDX.

The comments and votes are combined.

 

Thank you for your participation,

Andra

Jun 15, 2023 6:56 PM UTC

With the availability of lower cost 3D printers, for me this would be a game changer to be able to toggle it on/off in order to quickly print functional models and saving time not having to install helicoils, or for larger threads, not having to machine the thread in plastic.

 

 

Mar 20, 2025 12:49 PM UTC

1. Describe the Problem

Hello,

 

There is no option to create a physical Standard Thread in a model.
For example, I want to create a hole in a cylinder and add an internal UNC 7/16-14 thread inside the hole.

 

The current Hole feature includes a STANDARD mode - but it only adds a Cosmetic (NOT physical) standard thread.
Also, the Helical Sweep feature can create a physical thread, but it lacks STANDARD settings. So one cannot just choose UNC 7/16-14 thread, but is forced to find the measurements in a Machinery Handbook in order to create it manually.

 

I opened a case (C17735969) in PTC Support webpage but was answered that Creo does not have this  functionality OOTB. The user needs to manually add its engineering calculations for standard threads into Helical Sweep,

 

The need for physical  Standard Threads is mainly for 3D Printing of threaded elements (both internal and external).

 

Please add this feature in Creo Parametric inside the Hole feature or in Helical Sweep Feature.

 

Best Regards,

Michael

 

 

 


2. Are you using a workaround?
No workaround. Only manual calculations. A possible workaround would be to buy Taps and manually create the threads in a 3P-printed holed cylinder.

3. What is the use case for your organization?
The need for physical  Standard Threads is mainly for 3D Printing of threaded elements (both internal and external).

4. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization?
It is of great importance!

Mar 20, 2025 1:46 PM UTC

This request has 71 votes already https://community.ptc.com/t5/Creo-Parametric-Ideas/Creo-needs-a-modeled-thread-option/idi-p/458175

I would suggest adding your vote to it also.

Mar 20, 2025 4:59 PM UTC

While I have been known to say if the idea drives new sales, it will increase the chance of being implemented, in this case it should be something that PTC does need to do more to than just acknowledge the idea. This enhancement may not drive a lot of new sales, BUT it being an important feature requirement for 3D printing of parts, it will cause those looking for a CAD system to use with 3D printing to consider other options that have this feature.

As others have said, I would love if it was a toggle where we could choose between a cosmetic thread or a modeled thread for both internal and external areas.