Skip to main content
Sep 5, 2014 7:11 AM UTC
Archived

Config option inorder to disable the dimmension overide option

Related products:Creo Parametric

I'm doing configuration management on Creo in a rather large group of users. Recently, the practice of overriding dimension values have caused a considerable amount of costly problems.

Users copy old assemblies or parts that are in production, change the features that will differ on the new part, and then trust all the other dimensions that are already in use as if they are all parametric.

PTC has suggested a workaround of creating associative dimensions using show model annotations. (document – CS61225)

Unfortunately this is not a good solution as it only inhibits the user from using the function on that type of dimension.

The override can still be used, and there is no way of preventing the user from doing so.

I want to suggest that PTC makes two config options in order to address this.

-       -The first config will be to highlight or display non-parametric, dimensions. ( in order for detection of non-parametric dimmensions)

-       -The second will be to prohibit the override dimension functionality.

I’m sure a lot of people in production will agree that this can save a lot of money and hart ace, when it comes to quality issues and reworks.

17 replies

1-Visitor
Sep 9, 2014 6:56 AM UTC

I voted down, because there is the ModelCHECK option DIM_OVERWRITE to deal with overwritten dimension.

For details see page 50 and 150 in http://support.ptc.com/WCMS/files/111133/en/Help_Topic_Collection_Modelcheck.pdf.

alouwAuthor
Sep 9, 2014 9:21 AM UTC

Hi Domenic,. I hope I can sway your vote. I am aware of the config option in model check. It does'nt make sense to me why ptc would want to fix it in modelcheck afterwards and not have the option to prohibet it in the first place. good config practice would be just to not allow it in the first place.

Like I've mentioned. We are a large orginization and we had to switch model check off as a result of some limitations that model check has that was prohibiting us.

Sep 9, 2014 10:30 AM UTC

I use it frequently for notes, direction of grain on a wood part, ....

alouwAuthor
Sep 19, 2014 5:23 AM UTC

Dale, what you do is add text and not overiding dimmensions. What I do with adding text is put the @O sign in, in the text field, of the dimension properties, and put in the text.

The one that I'm talking about is the selection that is availible to overide dimmension that you can only ad numerical values. I just want to be able to restrict the avrage user from selecting that.

dim.jpg

All I'm suggesting is that they give the option to be able to switch the functionality off to select the option to overide the actual dimmension. Why would you want a different dimmension from what is there? It is bad configuration managment.

Because you can set the decimal values.

Apr 15, 2015 1:24 PM UTC

I agree with comments for the ability to turn this functionality on/off with a config option. We send dxf and step files on request to vendors for manufacturing assistance, and if dimensions are overidden, parts made from these files will not match the print dimensions. Very bad Configuration Management if we were to let this happen.

I'm mostly seeing inexperienced users using this option to"fake" dimensions, rather than to fix the geometry correctly. I like the flexibility of being able to overrride, just liked it much better when it was harder use.

Apr 15, 2015 4:28 PM UTC

I would also like some better ways to deal with the impact of using @O.  We have been burned several times by this.  One thought to to have a dimension feature that cannot be numerical so as not not allow "fake" dimensions.

Sep 10, 2015 1:35 PM UTC

This option is available to check drawing dimensions. What if you are doing MBD?

Sep 10, 2015 1:36 PM UTC

If a config.pro option isn't the answer the ability to identify overwritten dimensions on a drawing and in 3D annotations would be helpful.

Sep 10, 2015 2:37 PM UTC

ModelCHECK will report overwritten dimensions in drawings.  With the advent of MBD, it would be a good enhancement to ModelCHECK to note them in solids as well.

Sep 10, 2015 5:23 PM UTC

This is a good request. I think we can consider the possibility of allowing some administrative means of disabling the option, but at a minimum I think it would be good to enhance the Highlight By Attributes tool to highlight dimensions that are using the Override option and also to enhance the Find tool to allow these dimensions to be found via Search.