Skip to main content
Oct 1, 2018 12:25 PM UTC
Delivered

Bounding Box as a Feature

Related products:Creo Parametric

Bounding Box as a Feature

Please make a feature in Creo Parametric representing the smallest area or volume in which a design can fit, bounding box.

Please spend a few minutes looking at this video from SolidWorks, it is very simple and easy to understand.

Bunding Box

 

Chees Erik Sallingboe

50 replies

Feb 4, 2022 3:15 PM UTC

Expert Machinist already does this. I can get to it in Creo Design Essentials so licensing should not be an issue?

File - new - manufacturing.(sub type Expert Machinist)

Create Model. - give it some name."ABC"

Add the reference model (the part you want the stock to fit)

Create Stock. (adjust padding, Block vs Cylinder)

Done

Fix placement in mfg assembly.

Stock will be named similar to "ABC_WRK_01"

File Open In-Session to see the stock and its dimensions or even make a drawing with that stock part.

 

I have studied this on a few more complex parts and it seems to fit the stock very well to the minimum size.

 

Example Stock GenerationExample Stock Generation

Feb 4, 2022 3:26 PM UTC

@SweetPeasHub 

 

We in our company use the MFG molde cavity module, but we never tried to see if the machining Expert Machinist is available. I will try to do what you suggest. Thanks.

Feb 4, 2022 4:04 PM UTC

@SweetPeasHub 

 

I tried and indeed we can use the feature to get the stock size in Expert Machinist. So, the funcionality is what most of use want, but in part mode, instead of in assembly mode in a specific module. There is no need to have an assembly setup for the process, and creating another part only to get the dimensions that must be transferred back to the initial part to add to the BOM or to it's drawing.

 

Also, this is a simple algorithm since it get's only the solid bounding box. I don't know if it calculates it analytical, or if it uses the triangulation data to get the coordinates of the bounding vertices... I suppose getting the triangulation data would be better, since it has to be calculated anyway, and it's data that is available to send the 3D geometry to the graphics card. But in this Stock feature it's the user that specifies a CSYS to specify the orientation, whether the user chooses block, or cylinder. For me, it's enough this way. What some users have requested also, was for the orientation to be automatically calculated to get the optimum orientation to use the lowest volume or material weight for the part. In case of parts designed in place, in the context of the assembly, most can be modelled in not an axis aligned way, like a cylinder with the axis in the diagonal of a box. To have the bounding box of the cylinder use the least material, we would have to specify the axis of the cylinder. Or have improve the algorithm to let Creo search the most likely CSYS orientation.

 

Feb 4, 2022 4:10 PM UTC

Thanks for the information.

Then it should be very easy for PTC to add the requested Analysis feature to Part /Assembly mode. Should NOT have to create a manufacturing model for this functionality.

May 26, 2023 12:06 PM UTC
Status changed to: Implementation In Progress

this is currently under implementation.

If you want to be involved in upcoming Creo core modeling projects, you are invited to join the Creo 11/12-Core-Modeling-Projects-Working Group.

Creo 11/12 Core Modeling Projects - PTC Community 

You should find a button to send a join-request on that page.

Looking forward to it!

 

1-Visitor
Apr 18, 2024 10:07 AM UTC

I think, according to the Creo 11.0 Help Center site "Enhancement: Fast Bounding Box Calculation" this idea can be considered as delivered. 

Apr 18, 2024 1:12 PM UTC

It's a shame that edit definition must be invoked for the box/parameters to update, Why can't it be updated on regeneration?

Apr 18, 2024 1:18 PM UTC
Status changed to: Delivered

This enhancement is delivered in Creo 11. See "Enhancement: Fast Bounding Box Calculation"  

We are envisioning refinements of the capabilities for Creo 12, including "move-to-footer" and some others (hopefully also addressing the auto-update in assembly)

Apr 18, 2024 1:22 PM UTC

More comments in reply to Wayne

- auto-update is available in part mode

- in assembly mode, the challenge is not the update upon regen, but to reliably trigger regen when needed, but only when needed.

 A related question part of that discussion is also whether/when to update the bounding box when changing simp reps. 

Apr 18, 2024 1:55 PM UTC

@mneumueller From a large assy using simplified reps, i sincerely appreciate the "not on regen" concept. If introduced, I would highly encourage a config option to control the functionality.