Skip to main content
Oct 1, 2018 12:25 PM UTC
Delivered

Bounding Box as a Feature

Related products:Creo Parametric

Bounding Box as a Feature

Please make a feature in Creo Parametric representing the smallest area or volume in which a design can fit, bounding box.

Please spend a few minutes looking at this video from SolidWorks, it is very simple and easy to understand.

Bunding Box

 

Chees Erik Sallingboe

50 replies

Apr 12, 2019 12:48 PM UTC
Jlink has two bounding box functions: pfcSolid.Solid.GetGeomOutline and pfcSolid.Solid.EvalOutline. You probably want EvalOutline. EvalOutline includes copy geometry, and you supply the orientation. It does not find the minimum bounding box.
Jun 6, 2019 6:54 PM UTC

If this gets implemented there should be a geometry only option.

Jun 1, 2020 1:45 PM UTC

Good news: There is a new feature in Creo 7.0 called Enclosure Volume, which creates surface boundary box around model.

dresnik_0-1591018996837.png

 

Bad news: No boundary box parameters (x,y,z) are created.

Worse news: For Enclosure Volume feature to work, you need license for Generative Design. 

Worst news: Have not found it... yet. 🙂

Jun 3, 2020 12:35 PM UTC

Well, you are right, there is a new feature in Creo 7.0, Enclosure Volume

But as you are pointing out there are some bad news as well.

Actually, I thing there are to few improvements in Creo 7.0, and the Bounding Box should be very simple for PTC to implement

Jun 23, 2020 4:47 PM UTC
Status changed to: Under Consideration

set to "under consideration" as we can envision to enhance the Enclosure Volume feature to provide full Bounding Box functionality.

Still,  note that Creo 7.0 with multibody and the Enclosure Volume feature allow you to get to it quickly. 

Jun 24, 2020 5:58 AM UTC

Thanks for status change.

Sorry but the Enclosure Volume feature do not give the needed result, please look at the video from SolidWorks and the freedom the feature have.

 

Jul 3, 2020 6:30 PM UTC

It the calculation is too complicated (to find the minimum bouding box), there should be an option to only re-calculate it when needed, such as in mass properties.

If using the shading triangulation boudingbox, the minimum on X, Y, Z is already calculated, so those parameters should always be provided after each regeneration to be able to use the with, length and height in a BOM.

 

Sep 17, 2020 11:22 AM UTC

Hello
Knowing that modelcheck can give these 3 values in a single parameter. It should be possible to separate them into 3 parameters.

Dec 9, 2020 11:56 AM UTC

Today a designer needed to verify that segments of a piping assembly would fit inside a box for surface treatment. The way the parts are positioned inside that box never correspond with the default x-, y, z-coordinates of the Creo models. A search for a 'minimum bounding box' brought me here, but apparently without a helpful solution...

Dec 10, 2020 12:55 PM UTC

I think this feature should be provided both as parameters only, or also as a volume (with a quilt as in the Enclosed Volume) or better yet, as a solid construction body), with the option for the body to be shown in wireframe mode, or a semi-transparent shaded one.). Sometimes, having the dimensions is enough to use them for a Bill of Materials stock size dimensions, but if we rely only on the parameters values, we cannot visually inspect to see if the results are accurate. It's better to have both options, as a feature with a solid body geometry and also with 3 parameters (length, width, height, or Size_X, Size_Y, Size_Z).

 

Also it's important for the feature to have the option to be parametric, meaning, that the result is always regenerated and accurate (with a tolerance value). Leave the option to move the feature to the footer of the model tree, if we need only the final value to use in a BOM. If the feature is left in the middle of the model tree, we can get wrong results, if we add material later. But sometimes, we may want intermediate results, so, the feature should have the option to also be in the "middle" of a model tree.

 

The feature should also provide the option to give an offset in X, Y, and Z dimensions, as it does when calculatng the workpiece in MFG mold module, ie, leaving an offset for the stock around a machined part.

 

And since Creo has multibodies, the feature should also have the toption to include all solid bodies, or user specified ones, or excluding certain bodies from the bounding box calculation, if we want to calculate stock dimensions for different materials in a single part.

 

About the way to find the bounding box values, if we select the automatic regeneration update (as in weigh calculation), to avoid slowing down too much regeneration times, the bounding box vertices could be less accurate, and indeed use the triangulation of the surfaces used to send the triangles for the graphics card to shade the part. Most of the time, there is no need to have too much a rigorous calculation, specially if we have the option to give an offset around the calculated values to define the stock dimensions. It's better to have a very quick algorythm, even if less accurate, than a rigourous one, that takes too much time to update, and thus, cannot be used in "real-time", after each regeneration, thus, having to be manually invoked for all the parts in an assembly when trying to define the BOM, unless there is a way to automate this process.