Skip to main content
Apr 4, 2025 10:08 AM UTC
Acknowledged

Automatic update of the drawing format including tables on an existing drawing

Related products:Creo Parametric

1. Describe the Problem

Current behavior:

  1. Create a drawing and assign a drawing format that has tables (or use an existing drawing)
  2. Close and remove the drawing from the Creo session
  3. Change the tables on the format and revise the format
  4. Retrieve the drawing from step 1 again
  5. Frame geometry is updated, tables are not updated


2. Are you using a workaround?
Yes (see also CS174296): - In Layout > Document > Sheet Setup - Click the drop-down list and select another format, OK, Remove All - The select original format again, OK, Remove All

3. What is the use case for your organization?
We changed all our default drawing formats used for all drawings and also changed texts in tables in these formats. It's more effort and it's not straightforward to apply some additional steps to upgrade the format in each drawing.

4. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization?
For 1500 users there is a possible lost of 100hours/year; possible quality issues; misunderstanding/distraction because of outdated drawing format data shown

6 replies

Community Manager
Apr 4, 2025 10:55 AM UTC
Status changed to: Acknowledged

Thank you @_Marc_ for your idea. Based on the information you provided, we are acknowledging it as the Community management team. This is not a commitment from the Product team. Other users may comment and vote your idea up.

Apr 4, 2025 12:17 PM UTC

You cant automatically update all drawings that have ever used that particular format.

It would lead to changes being applied to existing drawings (possibly released) without any form of change control.

 

Having the tables copied into drawings rather than linked to drawings at least does allow you to update formats without changing all existing drawings.

_Marc_Author
Apr 4, 2025 12:33 PM UTC

@MH_10826452Thanks for your comment.


You cant automatically update all drawings that have ever used that particular format.

It would lead to changes being applied to existing drawings (possibly released) without any form of change control.


 That's not what we plan. Hence drawings that are revised (and with that action changed) should automatically get the revised format including the tables stored as part of the format during drawing retrieval.

 


Having the tables copied into drawings rather than linked to drawings at least does allow you to update formats without changing all existing drawings.

Interesting idea, hence formats are made to include format information. Adding this information (tables showing drawing parameters) directly on the drawing would make it even more complicated to update this information later on.

Apr 4, 2025 3:28 PM UTC

Currently, Creo copies the data from the format/template into your drawing. This leads to the issue of how do you update the drawings when the information in the format/template has changed. The current method is to replace the format and have it remove all tables and bring in the new/revised tables. This has caused us an issue because the drawing template also contains notes that are not in the format and thus do not get updated. I have put the new notes in the Notes folder so the user can retrieve them.

If the system were modified to link the drawing format/template to the user drawing, then whenever a drawing is opened in Creo, it would get the latest format or template information. This could lead to unauthorized changes being applied to drawings. If connected to Windchill, which it should be to handle the changes, then there should be a preference setting that controls the updating of the formats. Another requirement might be that only update if the format has the same name as the existing format. Revising formats makes it harder to do the current manual upgrade process since you have to replace the existing format with a temporary one, remove it from memory and then replace with the new version of the format. 

 

Apr 8, 2025 9:34 PM UTC

I believe your problem is the same as what I requested a change for back in 2013. I hope PTC will take note now and do something.

 

Create a drawing option to make formats 100% embed... - PTC Community

_Marc_Author
Apr 9, 2025 12:43 PM UTC

@BenLoosliLooks you had a lot of trouble with this. "This could lead to unauthorized changes being applied to drawings.", yes, needs to be looked at when PTC implements a solution. Nevertheless the issue (if any) is existent already now as all sketch and annotation elements from a linked format in Windchill are already now updated automatically in the drawing. It's "just" the tables (and table content) that is not automatically updated.

 

@WayneSchrockLooks quite the similar topic your idea from back in 2013. I also hope this idea here will not get archived before a solution is applied.

 

You may vote for this idea, so it gets more attention..