Skip to main content
Sep 5, 2024 6:18 PM UTC
Acknowledged

Assemblies in Generative Design

Related products:Creo Parametric

1. Describe the Problem

We need to be able to solve generative design on a single component that is within an assembly. I am aware that this will require adding contacts (at least bonded) for components in the assembly. It is very difficult, time consuming, and error prone when taking an assembly where a component is supporting multiple other components and convert that into a single component with multiple point masses and loads.


2. Are you using a workaround?
The workaround is to use other topology optimization software where assemblies are able to be used.

3. What is the use case for your organization?
The most basic example is a bracket which is supporting a few components. If you could include those supporting components and their material definition into an assembly, it would be far easier than trying to set up a system based on a single part.

4. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization?
The impact is that it takes users out of Creo Generative and leads to people having to learn other software outside of Creo.

4 replies

Community Manager
Sep 6, 2024 9:48 AM UTC
Status changed to: Acknowledged

Thank you @JB_8376379 for your idea. Based on the information you provided, we are acknowledging it as the Community management team. This is not a commitment from the Product team. Other users may comment and vote your idea up.

Sep 9, 2024 5:05 PM UTC

Could it not be solved by using Shrinkrwap to get to the sudy part the bodies of the ajacent parts of the assembly?

If generative design can work with multibody parts, a body could be used to represent the other components?

Oct 10, 2024 4:44 PM UTC

Hello S_Edgenear,

 

Let's propose a simple assembly of a bracket supporting a component. I want to be able to include the component being supported so I don't have to try to describe this with point masses, forces, and mass moments of inertia. It could be very complex if a bracket is supporting one or two items to try to describe that as a single component with loads and boundary conditions.

 

For your proposed idea of shrinkwrapping an assembly, I think there would be multiple problems. One of which would be defining the contact region(s) between the components. If they each share a large surface but are connected by a single bolt, we wouldn't want to assume the entire surface is "bonded" together as that would provide an unrealistic physics representation. 

 

If PTC just provided simple bonded contact interfaces between a couple of items in an assembly, it would keep some of these simple assembly problems simple and provide a lot of value.

Oct 10, 2024 7:05 PM UTC

In Creo 11 shrinkwraps can consist of independent solid bodies (multibodies) in which each body can inherit its properties from the component of the assembly, including its material density, this, mass properties. That could be a problem with the old shrinkwrap methods that would create a single volume in a single solid body. The problem with assemblies is that they could have moving parts, or unconstrained parts that would add a lot of complexity that would take much more time to try to solve. Having all the information inside a single part might create the oportunity for PTC to try to develop the missing features that you are trying to achieve.