Skip to main content
Feb 7, 2020 8:07 AM UTC
Acknowledged

Allow ModelCHECK to at least read PRO_MP_SOURCE and PRO_MP_MASS etc.

Related products:Creo Parametric

Please allow ModelCHECK to at least read the values of the mass properties Parameters like PRO_MP_SOURCE and PRO_MP_MASS, PRO_MP_ALT_MASS etc.

Like this the users could find out if a model hast set its mass properties to valid settings.

Often, there are imported models that get a material file set, but keep their mass source settings to PARAMETERS, and then all mass properties like center of gravity or inertia etc are not consistent. Or in the course of development, this or that material is used and the source may also be set to PARAMETERS at some point, but then geometry and maybe material changes before release, then it's also not consistent.

Allowing ModelCHECK to at least read those parameters would give the possibility of finding files that are not according to standards at all and preventing errors beforehand. Since this parameter is not automatically designated (and cannot be set via ModelUPDATE) one cannot simply run a report in Windchill as with other parameters.

 

4 replies

SvenRAuthor
Aug 5, 2024 12:01 PM UTC

I want to add that this is even more urgent now when being able to embed parts into assemblies: since you cannot run Modelcheck on the embedded parts, there is no viable way to verify most recent mass properties calculations have been run (e.g. run as last step before check-in to WIndchill).

Jan 23, 2025 10:29 AM UTC

I think PTC support just told me that ModelCHECK can not check if the mass properties are current.

Community Manager
Feb 12, 2025 9:47 AM UTC
Status changed to: Acknowledged

Hello,

Thank you for your idea. Based on the details and popularity of your idea, we are acknowledging it as the Community management team. This is not a commitment from the Product team.

Feb 20, 2025 12:49 PM UTC

Expanding on my previous comment:

 

It would be nice to have a parameter in Creo (MC_MP_CURRENT or similar) that can be designated, so the status of the mass properties can be shown in Windchill.

 

Also related to ModelCHECK and mass properties: material files

(PTC_MASS_DENSITY from material file with PRO_MP_SOURCE = "GEOMETRY" affects PRO_MP_MASS)

ModelCHECK can check the material file name, but the content of the file is not checked. This check (MATERIAL_INFO) in ModelCHECK also forces you to place all material files in a single directory, since it can't check in subdirectories of the material library (but avoids the issue of multiple files with the same name), but if you got ~ 600 material files that is an issue.

Regarding the multiple files issue: we would be fine with ModelCHECK verifying that the material file is contained (based on the file content) in the material library.

Why check the material file content: we use the Access attribute of parameters in the material file and would like to notify users if the assigned material file is not current.