Allow MBD Hole Note to be according to ISO 129-1 , no capital X
1. Describe the Problem
As of https://www.ptc.com/en/support/article/CS351946 the hole note token exclusively conforms to ASME standard Y14.5 section 1.9.5 and does not adhere to ISO 129-1 since it consists of a capital 'X' letter.
In standard ISO 129-1 chapter "Repeated dimensions" it is stated: 'When a feature is repeated on the drawing, it is possible to simplify the indication of its dimension on the drawing by indicating:
— on one instance of the feature, the nominal dimension (with a property indicator symbol if appropriate), preceded by the associated number of repetition, followed by a multiplication symbol (×) and a space (e.g. 2× ⌀18).
Since this also applies to MBD hole notes, we Creo users cannot use the token that evaluates from HOLE_INSTANCE_X_SYMBOL because it always results in a capital 'X'.
On the other hand, PTC claims Creos MBD features to be conforming to ISO 129 multiple times, and there is even a DTL setting for a similar requirement that also results in using the multiplication sign:
DTL setting datum_target_area_multiply_sign:
Default and Available Settings:
• capital_X*—For ASME symbols, set this value when displaying datum target area for a rectangle.
• lowercase_x—For ISO symbols, set this value when displaying datum target area for a rectangle.
• multiplication_sign—For ISO symbols, set this value when displaying datum target area for a rectangle.
So this idea is to support conforming to ISO 129-1 where ISO mode is used (not everywhere).
Of course, this is a mutual exclusive thing - it cannot be at the same time × and X, as models are not at the same time metric and imperial in tolerance mode.
Ideally that would be without any interaction for the user, but it would also make sense to introduce a DTL option like above, or even treat this hole note topic as part of an existing DTL option for MBD.
Best Regards
2. Are you using a workaround?
no workaround except manually editing each hole note - who should pay that?
3. What is the use case for your organization?
Use case is to be compliant with ISO 129-1 which is also a prerequisite for some suppliers in automotive for example.
4. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization?
We advise not to use hole notes as the result using them would mean too much manual work.
