Skip to main content
Jun 28, 2023 6:58 PM UTC
Acknowledged

Allow "Circular Trim" to be Set as Default

Related products:Creo Parametric

Current Version 8.0.8.0


The default Fillet option in sketcher is "Circular" which adds construction lines to all fillets.

These construction lines are only useful when needing to dimension the theoretical sharp corner, which is rare and usually non-preferred since it is difficult to measure.

For most fillets, the "Circular Trim" option is preferred, which creates no extraneous construction entities.

 

The "Circular" construction lines add unneeded complexity to the sketch, and when the sketch changes, they frequently become detached.

Since the construction lines are not deleted automatically when the fillets are deleted and sketches get littered with extra construction lines that are not used.

They can cause unintended modeling constraints and even incorrect geometry.

In complex sketches that have been through multiple iterations and handed off to multiple people, the extraneous construction lines start to stack up and cause the sketch to slow down.

This is especially pronounced when inexperienced users are involved in the iteration process.

 

This results in increased design time in having to set the "circular trim" option every time (usually having to delete previous fillets because , even as an experienced user, I forget to set it at first).

It also results in increased rework time having to find and delete errant construction lines left over from deleted fillets in models that have been handed off.

 

PTC, please allow "Circular Trim" to be set as the default fillet for the sketcher.

2 replies

Jun 28, 2023 7:28 PM UTC

I just tried this on 7.0.11.0:

 

While in a sketch, RMB in the ribbon and select "Customize the Ribbon" in the pop-up menu.

Expand Sketching and fillet.

Select Circular Trim and use the up arrow to move it to the top.

The top function of a multi functiion button will be the default.

 

I agree with your frustration and now have a solution for me.  Rolling this out to all users is beyond my expertise.

Jun 29, 2023 7:02 AM UTC
Status changed to: Acknowledged

Hi @dhermosillo!

Thank you for your idea. Based on the information you provided, we are acknowledging it as the Community management team. This is not a commitment from the Product team. Other users may comment and vote your idea up.