Adding a location from a point to a Flat Ribbon should not introduce twisting!
1. Describe the Problem
Please reference:
Ticket: 16206056
SPR: 13491483
We created geometry points on a sketch such that we can help route a ribbon cable thru those points within the cabling module. When trying to add location, and specify those points, the ribbon becomes twisted. According to R&D, this is per design as the path of the ribbon will be parallel to the sketching plane that the point was created on. Where-as, if it was a regular datum point, it simply goes thru the point, like you would expect. If we were sketching, we would need to do it on a plane that is perpendicular to the direction we want the ribbon to travel.
This is not ideal for many reasons, including:
- I don't believe this concept of a direction being dictated by the reference plane of an object was ever used before. Up until we had PTC write this article, it was unknown. A typical user would not think this is how it should behave, based on how the tool behaves in other situations.
- If we had to create a sketch perpendicular to the direction of travel, we would need to create many sketches. It is much easier to create one sketch with multiple points for the ribbon to travel through.
- This adds unnecessary complexity and confusion, making it even harder for the user to try and use this module, as intended, instead of using the regular module with a few simple sweeps.
2. Are you using a workaround?
We don't use the cabling module much, especially for ribbons, because of it's lack of being user-friendly and inconsistent with work-flows.
3. What is the use case for your organization?
We would like to have our 3d designs be as accurate as possible, including wiring, cables and ribbons. However, instead of modeling with sweeps in 10 minutes, it took us much longer trying to deal with the issues of 'twisting' with the ribbon.
4. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization?
Almost all user's won't go near the cabling module due to this and many other similar issues regarding it's user-friendliness (or lack-there-of).
