Skip to main content
Apr 19, 2017 8:28 PM UTC
Archived

Add functionality: Multi Body part

Related products:Creo Parametric

Add Multi Body part functionality within part-mode, so within one part several sub-parts can we indentified for example a weld-part consisting several tubes in 1 part. Due to the Multi model part the assembly is not needed and external references are avoided. Also  copying of bodys within a part is more easy when using Multi bodies. Multi body parts are also very helpfull for creating shell meshes when doing analyses with FEM- software like Ansys Workbench

22 replies

Apr 12, 2018 7:26 PM UTC

Agreed! This is the #1 functional advantage SW has over Creo.

Apr 13, 2018 3:16 PM UTC

Don't hold your breath for this change. It goes down to the core of the PTC design principle and the coding of Granite One.

SolidWorks was initially using Parasolid as their core modeling kernel and it has always allowed multiple bodies in a file. When they switched to the CATIA kernel, it too must have allowed multiple bodies in a file. Not sure if CATIA does, but since the kernel does, I would guess it does, too.

 

PTC's design philosophy has always been individual files for all components and then bring them together in an assembly.

3-Newcomer
Apr 13, 2018 3:55 PM UTC

As Ben said, Creo (Proe at the time) was built around the idea that the database should reflect reality.  So, there are no multi body parts in the real world (that would be multiple parts), so not in Creo.  You may remove material at the assembly level (drilling holes at assy, etc.) but you don't add material (welds being an exception), so no assembly protrusions, only assy cuts.

 

So, I agree doubt that PTC will be adding this, even though it would be handy in many scenarios aside from simulating actual parts.

 

BTW - Ben, where did you read that SW switched kernels?  It's been rumored for some time, but I can't find any documentation that it's actually happened.

Apr 14, 2018 1:41 AM UTC

Work is under way.  There was a public call for working group members some time back.  Here is a screenshot from the list of active working groups:

Multi-Body Working Group.png

Apr 16, 2018 7:48 PM UTC

Doug - I did more research into the SW kernel. Dassault has said they want all of their products on the V6 kernel, however that is for new products only, like SolidWorks Experience. The original SolidWorks will stay, for now, on Parasolid. Dassault owns their own V6 kernel of CATIA and the ASICS kernel they bought plus they license the Parasolid kernel from Siemans(UG).

Jul 23, 2018 11:41 AM UTC

I am a new subscriber to Creo+ISDX. We have a couple of licenses of SolidWorks here, alongside Rhino and Fusion 360. I have used SolidWorks for 20 years. Back in the day, I was one of the early promoters of multi bodies in parts for SolidWorks, as this is the way we modelled in systems like Ashlar Vellum Cobalt and Think Design. CATIA, NX, SolidEdge, Inventor, SolidWorks all handle multi body parts.

When we looked at Creo, our focus was on Freestyle and ISDX. This was the main reason for us to expand our software base. We had very specific issues to deal with in the workflow using SubD methods - we use Power Surfacing in SolidWorks and Tsplines with Rhino and Fusion 360. Freestyle is an excellent product, but it needs the multi body approach to really work effectively.

So why multi body parts? In my (20 year) experience modelling in this way I can put it down to a few things:

 

1. Top Down master model approach - we can model in context in a part then save out bodies as parts - associatively. Update the part model, the saved out parts update, and any assemblies that use them as well. This approach is particularly important with assemblies that are made up of fixed parts - like enclosures, plastic toys, etc. You can model top down in assemblies in SolidWorks as well but for these "simple" static assemblies (often made up of complex bodies) multi body parts make things much simpler.

2. Modelling specific features - such as complex patterns than change relationship to a surface. As an example, think of a dimple feature on a double curvature surface - very common. In designing these featues I want to vary the depth or height of the dimple relative to the surface. I SolidWorks I would create a dimple body and position it above the surface or tie it to a control surface used to vary the feature depth. I then pattern the body across the surface. I then boolean cut the bodies from the base surface. Update the control surface , the relative depth of the dimple changes. very controllable, very quick, very easy. Try doing that with features alone.

3. Design exploration - sometimes when designing you need to move bodies around, see how they interact, try different approaches. With a feature only approach this is much more complex. It needs to be planned.

 

That last one is I think the issue here. We use CAD to DESIGN. We do not use it to DOCUMENT. If I know what I am going to model I can use any CAD system on the market. If I am using CAD to explore form, edit and tweak I need specific workflows and tools. Creo has a fantastic tool in Freestyle. I want to continue to use it, but if we cannot resolve how to create parts as efficiently as we do now in other systems, I will not be renewing the subscription - which is sad. I have a lot of other SolidWorks using designers looking at our little Creo experiment with interest.

 

I would be very happy for anyone at PTC to visit me to see how we actually do things, so they really understand the benefits this modelling approach brings. Right now, from what I can see and read, I'm not convinced PTC "get" the issue. I don't see how it is related to the kernel. All a solid is is a stitched up surface, and you have multiple "surface" bodies in a part. In any case you do have multi bodies in parts as long as they don't intersect.

 

 

Aug 16, 2018 3:03 PM UTC

KQD (et al),

as a member of the Creo Product Management Team I can tell you that multi-body support is currently an active project within Creo R&D.

I would be very much interested in talking to you to discuss your use cases and will contact you via e-mail.

Best regards,

Martin Neumueller

Oct 18, 2018 9:49 AM UTC

Coming from NX and Catia background it was strange for me to find that I cannot make multiple bodies in Creo and boolean them together, this was key for collaborative modelling particularly in complex injection mouldings. I would be interested in how this develops, currently I don't think the workflow is as efficient as Catia and NX.

Oct 18, 2018 10:27 AM UTC

All,

if you are interested to join the working group, we would be happy to have you join.

Note that the above mentioned previous working group "embedded components" has moved to a more general "multi-body working group".

 

I would be very interested discussing all of the above mentioned use cases, in particular also including the collaborative modeling, and master model design aspects.

 

Thanks and best regards,

Martin Neumueller

 

 

 

Oct 18, 2018 1:45 PM UTC

khimani_mohiki,

 

What advantage does multi body parts give you over the existing Boolean functionality in Creo Parametric?  (In assembly mode, search for "Component Operations" if you're not familiar with the functionality.)

 

Regards,

Dan N.