Skip to main content
Feb 7, 2024 8:15 PM UTC
Acknowledged

Add drop down menu for copy geometry similar an inheritance feature to show the features

Related products:Creo Parametric

Please include detailed documentation such as screenshots, images or video.

1. What product and version are you running?
Creo 9.0.7


2. What is the problem?
There is no easy way to select copy geometry features

3. Are you using a workaround? If yes, please describe it.
I am using the find command to find the features

4. What is the use case for your organization? Describe how your idea would work in context or how it would apply to a practical situation.
I would like copy geometry features to fold out with the features that they contain like an external inheritance does.

 

This:

Capture3.PNG

Does this:

Capture.PNG


5. What impact does this problem currently have on your organization? (Number of users affected, hours of lost productivity, etc.)

It would allow the user to pick copy geometry features easier (within the GUI)

6 replies

Feb 8, 2024 7:33 AM UTC
Status changed to: Acknowledged

Hi @Chris3!

Thank you for your idea. Based on the information you provided, we are acknowledging it as the Community management team. This is not a commitment from the Product team. Other users may comment and vote your idea up.

Feb 8, 2024 11:24 PM UTC

It does not make sense.

The copy Geometry as the name says, copies the geometry and not the features.

Feb 10, 2024 1:42 AM UTC

@S_Edgenear , Note that in the "References" collector, one can put features inside the copy-geometry: namely datum features and also previous copy geoms features:

pausob_1-1707529166099.png

And anyway, there could be a list of IDs for curves, surfaces, quilts - displayed and selectable from the model tree when specifying reference  geometry (instead of picking it in the graphics area),  This may be beneficial as often the copy geom feature is a construction feature that is hidden by layer rules or even the current model geometry.

Also: it would be cool if one could name the entities inside publish-geometry feature and those would show up in the target model as menu-selectable chains, quilts, datums etc...

Chris3Author
Feb 12, 2024 3:34 PM UTC

@S_Edgenear The idea is exactly what @pausob said, thank you for the clarification @pausob ! I understand it is geometry, but Creo is holding that geometry in the background as quilts, curves and datums. I am asking that those geometry features be selectable. In the case of datums the datums of the datums (and names) come through (they can be found with the find tool or graphically in the UI). Datums are individual entities so why not list them as sub-features the same way that they are in an inheritance feature? For quilts it would provide another way to select that quilt for applying an appearance for instance.

Feb 28, 2024 8:37 PM UTC

What I would add, and it was already a requested idea that simply got deleted or archived, is the ability to collect sketches and be able to select a wholly copied sketch both on the screen or on the fold out list underneath the copy geometry feature. Currently we have to copy individual entities inside a sketch, and on the target part, we would need to create another sketch, using those lines, circles, arcs to reconstruct a new sketch as a feature to be able to use in downstream features, such as extrudes or revolves. If we try to use points inside a sketch to make a point sketch pattern and want to maintain design intent, currently it's not possible, If we add or delete a new point on the original sketch, we have to remember to add the new point in the "overlapped" sketch on the target part, to be able to use the same locations. If we delete a point in the original sketch, we get an error message on the derived sketch and are able to solve the problem, deleting an uneeded point. But if we add points on the original sketch, there is no way to maintain a one to one relationship in the derived reconstructed sketch on the target part. So, an ability to be able to copy selected whole sketches on the original part to a derived part would be extremely useful. And as on this OP request, those sketches should be able to be shown and be selectable as a regular sketch if the user expands the node under the Copy Geometry feature. Currently we can only transfer sketches and maintain one to one relationships in a derived part and be able to use them for sketch patterns is when we create an "Inheritance" feature instead of a copy geometry. But this has the extreme disadvantage that it tries to transfer too much information (all the features on the original part and it's geometry minus the supressed features). So, currently there is no way to copy only some user selectable Sketches from a source part to a destination part, which is something that other CAD packages can easily do, for instance, Solid Edge, and this is a very good method to use in TOP DOWN design. 

Feb 28, 2024 8:43 PM UTC

I also agree with @pausob that in the case of geometry edge chains that it would be useful to display them as a user selectable item as sub-nodes on expandable Copy Geometry feature, and also to display a list of quilts or bodies for quick and easier selection.. I prefer to select geometry references on the model tree than on the graphics window to avoid circular references, since axis, planes, csys, points, etc, can be overlapped on the graphics screen on different sub-assemblies, and in the case of quilts or bodies, they might be hidden it would be easier to select them on the model tree, than search for them, unhide them, select on the screen, and hide them again.