Skip to main content
Feb 26, 2019 3:20 PM UTC
Archived

A Configure BOM for Windchill tool

Related products:Creo Parametric

There is a way to link the line numbers or find numbers between WindChill and Creo as documented:

and other places. This is a good starting point. However, this requires manual entry of the values within the model tree for the component level parameters. The issue with this is that Creo will fail checkin of an assembly if, for example,:

  1. There are 10 of the same screws and only 9 have the findnumber field entered (you missed one)
  2. There are 10 screws and you gave some of them one find number and others a different find number (you forgot some of these screws were higher up in the model tree with an already assigned number)
  3. You gave these 10 screws a find number that was already assigned to something else

 

Getting the values entered correctly, effectively and quickly is almost impossible in even "smallish" assemblies when:

  • Components are embedded in groups
  • Components are embedded in patterns
  • Similar Components are spread out throughout the model tree
  • You don't have access to an easy table within the assembly to view everything, like a BOM table with a quantity.

 What do other people do? Is there a company that makes a toolkit that can just autoconfigure the component level parameters and manage them automatically? It shouldn't be too hard to do. Any change to a line number should just get propagated throughout the component level parameters to all of the same components. Otherwise, I would love for PTC to create a tool to do this. Whether at the assembly module, drawing module or both. 

 

Thoughts and comments on this by user's and PTC would be great. If you developed a tool-kit app, please let me know. If you have inventive solutions, I would love to hear it. We are trying to expand our use of Windchill and this was a definite topic of conversation. We don't want duplicate work in entering find numbers in drawings and Windchill. Yet, that is still easier than trying to manage the model tree with the issues discussed above.

 

 

5 replies

Feb 27, 2019 12:49 AM UTC

Joe,

Back about 10+ years ago, we had written a specification to have a toolkit program for a GUI to assign the find number to the components in an assembly as you described.  The specification included the ability to automatically or manually assign some or all the find numbers, lock all or individual find numbers, reset/reorder all or individual find numbers, skip find numbers [for deleted objects, or placeholders for non-modeled items], etc.  We also included the ability to assign different models the same find number to account for times when different models are used to represent the same object [e.g. potting material used to fill different cavities].  A local vendor did quote us on creating the tool, but we could not secure funding to purchase it at the time.  The price was certainly reasonable.

 

I did ask the question to PTC two years ago at the LiveWorx event about PTC creating such a program themselves.  It was not on their radar at that time.

 

As an FYI, to help assign the find number for multiple identical objects all at once, in your workspace, you can view the information page of the assembly, use the structure tab, merge the uses [to show the quantity > 1], and add the FN parameter to the table display.  An image is shown in Steve Shaw's document; page 11, the bottom most view.  You can then simply enter the FN value once per row, and all the individual items for that row will be assigned that FN.  Granted you can still run into the other issues you have pointed out, but it helps some especially when you have a large number of the same hardware in your assembly.

 

When we eventually link our Pro/Intralink system to our PDM system, we may revisit having the GUI created.  It all depends on the capabilities of the program used to link the two systems.

 

Regards,

Dan N.
BAE Systems

jwaghAuthor
Feb 27, 2019 2:32 PM UTC

Dan,

Good to hear back from you. I remember our good ol' times when I worked for BAE out of Greenlawn and then Wayne and we had some teleconference meetings together. 

I appreciate your comments and feedback. Can you send me any info on the vendor who quoted out the job? We can do this via PM if you wish. I am aware of editing it from the WTPart level. Currently, we do not use WTParts. That will be implemented when we roll out WindChill as part of our PDM system. However, building a cad model from a WTPart has its own challenges. For instance, if the assembly is already checked out, access control, if it is open in session and then updated, etc. 

My current plan, if I can't find a better solution, is to use a mix of advanced mapkeys and batch files to propagate the parameters based on predefined company rules. I've already done something similar where I propagate the REF DES values from the EEs BOM into our Boards to be used for ECAD/MCAD collaboration.

Feb 27, 2019 3:52 PM UTC
Joe, We still run Pro/Intralink which doesn't have the capabilities for WTParts, and the WS modification worked for us (we had it setup on one of out test servers for quite some time.) You will be viewing the information of the .asm file in your local WS, not the CS version. Review the image from Steve's document again, no WTParts or interaction is needed for setting the FN parameters. I will email you separately with the vendor information. Regards, Dan N.
jwaghAuthor
Feb 27, 2019 4:28 PM UTC

True. I guess once you add the linenumber/findnumber attributes you can edit them from the cad document. It still is not efficient at all.

olivierlp
Community Manager
Apr 4, 2023 5:29 PM UTC
Status changed to: Archived

Hello,

We are archiving your idea as part of a general review. This action is based on the age of your idea and the total number of votes received, as per this announcement.

You can always post a new idea with all the details required in the form.

Thank you for your participation.

Olivier