Skip to main content
8月 15, 2017 3:39 下午 UTC
已解决

Responsive Layout to any cost??

Hi there,

 

who else is annoyed by ptc new layout for the forum?

Sure, maybe it looks more like 2017 than before, but is responsive design everything?

To me, the new layout is just wasting space and bloats everything up so You keep on scrolling, scrolling, scrolling.

Here are some more specific issues:

  • Somewhat between 30 and 50 % of the screen is just blank space (wasteful), especially in topics
  • Almost no differentiation between "normal" text and clickable content
  • blog is gone
  • "my profile" is nothing more than a timeline
  • browser integrated spell checking does not work

Maybe the new site looks gorgeous on tablets and phones. But how many ptc-product-using-engineers design their stuff on their phones?

 

Mat回答
9月 11, 2017 3:44 下午 UTC

For the record, I moved my blog to

https://circularreferencessite.wordpress.com/

 

If You do not want to type the URL, just scan the QR-Code in my avatar (unfortunately, there is also no more option to post something "personal" on the "about you" page of this forum).

 

4回复

8月 15, 2017 5:36 下午 UTC

Good day @Mat

Thanks for these suggestions - we are working on the UX issues to make navigation easier.

For lost content or other issues, would you please use this link to report them?

Thank you,

Toby

Mat作者
8月 16, 2017 7:41 上午 UTC

@Tmetcalf wrote:

Good day @Mat

Thanks for these suggestions - we are working on the UX issues to make navigation easier.

For lost content or other issues, would you please use this link to report them?

Thank you,

Toby


I think You don' t get it.

The content is still there, but there is no more blog. Instead, all posts have been dumped in "Creo Modeling Questions".

All links to the blog are now dead. Thanks for nothing.

Mat作者回答
9月 11, 2017 3:44 下午 UTC

For the record, I moved my blog to

https://circularreferencessite.wordpress.com/

 

If You do not want to type the URL, just scan the QR-Code in my avatar (unfortunately, there is also no more option to post something "personal" on the "about you" page of this forum).

 

8月 15, 2017 8:22 下午 UTC

Hi Mat!

If you look around here a bit you'll see that you are not alone!

Usability here is really bad and navigation unneccessary cumbersome.

The change from Jive to Lithium sure wasn't a step to the better, rather a step to the cheaper.

Wasting space is seen here wherever you look.

I used to have a customized group in the old Jive forum and the main part of it was a widget which collected posts from whatever section I would be interested in and showed them in chronological order. So usage was clicking on the bookmark for this page, enter login data and the immedeatly without any more clicks or having to scroll I would have seen the newest posts from all sections and entering a thread was just one click away.

What a differnce to what I have now.

I use links to the sections I am interested in, e.g.  https://community.ptc.com/t5/PTC-Mathcad/ct-p/PTCMathcad

Here I see an overview and can look IF there are any new posts in Mathcad Ideas, Blogs or Questions. I don't see which posts - I would have to go to this section to see. How cumbersome!

But even worse - before I can look at that overview I have to scroll down, as at the top of the page we have that unnecessary "New Solutions" section which I honestly can't imagine anybody could benefit from.

So I suggested at least to elimiate that section to give us quicker access to the information we are interested in.

Answer from PTC:
Status:   We don’t have the ability to delete the New Solutions sections at this time.  We will be closing out this issue.   

A blatant lie in my opionion. Sure the owner of the forum has the ability to move around and place the section wherever he thinks they belong and he can also omit ot. Other Lithium driven forums show clearly that the look is highly custimizable - e.g. the Lithium Community itself (BTW with much better, more condensed menus).

So "We don't have the ability to .." seems to be PTC speech for "We absolutely are not willing to put some work to change anything. Use our forum scrolling your way to the information and if you don't like that, leave". Something I have to think about.