Skip to main content
Sep 29, 2016 1:03 PM UTC
Question

Student Files vs Commercial Files

Before I submit a product idea, I was wondering if there was an existing way to notify users of the Community if the attached files are student or commercial.  I would like to see a way to notify users if they are going to upload a student file or a commercial file to let the readers know in advance of what kind of file it is.  So many times I have downloaded a file to work on and found out it was a student version of Creo, a file that cannot be opened in a commercial version.

11 replies

Sep 29, 2016 4:42 PM UTC

Good day Steven,

This would be a product idea for Jive and I am happy to pass it along, but do not see it as being very popular outside our community.

I agree the version / file type should be indicated in the body of the questions.  Just like asking people to mark answers correct or not posting the entire question into the title of the discussion; I think this can be solved through community communication.  I ask everyone to please indicate the file type (commercial or student) within the body of their question and I will do my best to ensure all student live in and get moved to PTC Academic Program

Please let me know if I have missed what you are seeking.

Best,

Toby

Sep 30, 2016 12:16 AM UTC

It;s too bad. Under UNIX and Linux I think that the magic file could have a classification added to it to identify the files based on their contents. magic(5): file command's magic pattern file - Linux man page

It would also allow identifying the version of software used to create the file.

Oct 4, 2016 2:16 PM UTC

You are right Steven -

I see a major part of my role within this community is to be the "librarian:" ensure discussions and content are placed into the right space.

I like the idea of guidance pop ups to be available, but Jive would need to build them. 

Again, I believe the best way to make this happen is we all work together to educate and set expectations with our members.

Cheers,

Toby

Oct 5, 2016 5:41 AM UTC

Toby,

I also prefer user education to upgrading of Jive functionality .

MH

Oct 5, 2016 1:25 PM UTC

Steven,

how do you think Jive recognizes student files automatically ? Jive knows nothing about contents of Creo files. Therefore they must cooperate with PTC on implementation. ... and guess what happens ? Nothing .

Possible variant solution .... implemention of access rights.

  • Commercial users have full access (read/wite) to any branch of community web
  • Student/Academic have full access (read/wite) to Academic branch of community web, only ... and read access to others

Again cooperation with PTC is necessary.

"Users education" solution

School CAD admins can educate their students to post their question in Academic branch, only.

Available immediately. Unfortunately school CAD admins do not educate their students.

MH

Oct 6, 2016 1:51 AM UTC

I figure the Academic side should field questions specific to that license type. How to use Creo should be in the main Creo path. There aren't that many Academic questions anyway and I see most of them result from not understanding either the licensing or the appropriate hardware.

For those of us with no personal or access to work licenses for non-work use, attaching files of any type is of no use. Often just a png file to show what they are seeing is sufficient.

Oct 5, 2016 1:48 PM UTC

Steven,

I do not believe that "dummy person" selects the appropriate file type, when he/she is asked. And others will be punished, because they will have to do one more step.

MH

Oct 5, 2016 2:32 PM UTC

I stated that there would have to be a pop-up window when attaching files, and that pop-up window would have functionality to notify readers if the file is student or commercial.

I hate to complicate things, but that pop-up would have to be restricted to certain forums. There is no such distinction with Mathcad files, and therefore it would create immense confusion.

Oct 6, 2016 5:53 AM UTC

> There is no such distinction with Mathcad files,

Hmmm - Prime 3.0 vs 3.1 ? 😉

The solution can be provided by PTC only. DIfferent file format in their products - different extension.

Oct 5, 2016 5:03 PM UTC

Not to make light of the request Steven; I agree with you, but how to do it?

Just Do.png