Skip to main content
May 5, 2014 10:57 AM UTC
Question

Re: Very painful switching from SolidWorks to Pro/E

Here's the article:

    1 reply

    May 6, 2014 5:09 AM UTC

    Ok, thanks.

    I was expecting a more quantitative or in-depth qualitative comparison.

    I'm holding to my end-point evaluation method as a comparison basis. Look at what features are added to the model, look at what setup is required to initiate those features, and look at how obvious it is to the user to get the setup correct for the features they need. Just before clicking the Go button is the software endpoint. It's between where user input stops and the software actually performs the task.

    I suppose allowances need to be made for non-native endpoints. E.g. as far as I know, there is no swept solid feature from PTC as there is from SW, but one might still make an effort to see how difficult it is to create a comparable result. For all I know, there are a ton of mismatched software endpoints between these and other CAD systems. Without a list or other means to compare the number, kind, and ease/obviousness of use, most of what's gotten in reviews is simple preference.

    I remember going to an evening demo at McAuto of UG and seeing how speedy it was. But I wondered, what size computer was on the other end of the terminal and did it remain this fast with a dozen other users attached. Still lacking usable info from software suppliers today.