Skip to main content
Dec 11, 2014 12:16 PM UTC
Question

Re: Units, understanding Run Status, where to find units, example force = ?? units

Dave,

Did my post provide the answer?

    3 replies

    Dec 11, 2014 4:29 PM UTC

    Hi Steven,

    If you can see this image in post (I can not figure out how you were able to make your image enlarge with a click - I would appreciate if you would tell me how you do that.

    Back to the reply, - if you can not see the image, see the attachment.

    I have never really dug into the units, but I think i have found what I am looking for. Maybe...

    Your reply is correct - but I think this will work as well.

    In the "units" menu, I see you can select " Force Length Time (FLT)", then for "Force" select "Kg-F".. but the Mass changes to mm-kg/sec^2. I think I understand why the Mass changes to mm-kg/sec^2 [But, these values have to be converted to Kilogram-Force for 99% of the Managers / Clients to understand.

    I have to experiment with these "units" in the "part" level and "Assembly" level and see How Mechanica see the units in the "Reports / Summary" dialog.

    I will keep you posted.

    The goal is "Length" = millimeters, "Mass" = Kilogram, "Force" = Kilogram-Force, "Time" = Seconds, "Temperature" = Celisus. Then to have Mechanica / Simulate to report results in these units mention earlier.

    99% of the time, I have to convert mm-kg/sec^2 to Kilogram-Force/Sec^2. If I am doing my conversion correctly, I divide by 1000, Example 1500mm-kilograms/sec^2 (Force) / 1000 (mm to kilograms) = 1.5kilogram-Force.

    12-11-2014+11-04-12+AM.png

    Dec 12, 2014 8:59 AM UTC

    Hi David,

    The goal is "Length" = millimeters, "Mass" = Kilogram, "Force" = Kilogram-Force, "Time" = Seconds, "Temperature" = Celisus

    Unfortunately, this is not possible due to the definitions of the various physical quantities. You have to have "consistent units" - here are a couple of the top hits from Googling that:

    http://www.dynasupport.com/howtos/general/consistent-units

    http://femci.gsfc.nasa.gov/units/

    Basically, you only need to define three of the key units (plus temperature), and the remainder will all be derived from those. Typically those three 'base units' can be mass-length-time or force-length-time.

    For example, standard SI units are mass-length-time (kg-metre-second), and force is a derived unit of 1 N = 1 kg.m/s^2 (mass × acceleration). If you choose other base units, such as millimetres, then the derived units change accordingly.

    If it's any help, I prefer to use Mechanica in N-mm-s, so that stress is directly in MPa (N/mm^2). I then have to remember that masses are in tonnes (1 N = 1 t.mm/s^2) and torques are in N.mm, but I find these quantities relatively easy to work with.

    I think that Creo has some improvements over Wildfire versions in handling different units, and possibly allowing selection of different units in the results window - but I agree that this doesn't help with the output in the run summary file.

    Dec 12, 2014 2:31 PM UTC

    Yup,

    Newton's 2nd law must be obeyed

    F=ma

    1N=1kg x 1m/s^2

    if you use mm then to still get 1N of force you must have 1000kg (1mm is 1/1000m and therefore the acceleration is 1mm/s^2 which is 1/1000th m/s^2. 1/1000th the acceleration requires 1000 times the mass to still get 1N out)

    if you continue with mm and kg then your forces are mN.

    1 kilogram force is different. It is 1kg accelerated by 1g (9.81m/s^2) or 9.81N in earth's gravity. You would need to divide an answer by g to know how many kgf you have. Remember 1g when using length unit of mm is 9810mm/s^2.

    Soooo,,

    In your principal system of units, mm kg s, obeying Newton's 2nd law, you interpret the summary output as :

    Distances (measures etc) are in mm

    Masses is in kg

    Forces must be in mN (1/1000 N)

    Moments mN.mm

    Pressures mN/mm^2

    What sometimes confuses are the units in the force/moment dialog.

    again, look at Newton's 2nd law.

    1N=1kg x 1m/s^2

    or the units of N could be written as m.kg / s^2 but we use 'N'.

    1mN=1kg x 1mm/s^2

    mN = mm.kg/mm^2

    Build a 1x1x1 block with unit load and reaction measures and play.

    ttfn