Skip to main content
Dec 9, 2016 2:06 PM UTC
Question

Re: Solidify/Cut issue in Creo Simulate containing an assembly with pattern

rrabe,

I have not done an in-depth study of your 3D model, but is it possible that you could achieve the same results using 2D contact as shown in page 7 in the attached file?  If so, this would be a much better approached than 3D.  But I really don't know what you are trying to achieve.

    1 reply

    Dec 13, 2016 9:42 AM UTC

    Hello

    Thank you for pointing out.

    Yes, specifically for this model I think the 2D simulation can be an option because I have a similar construction as in your presentation. Actually I almost forgot this way because most of the other studies could not be described in 2D due to the direction of the load and/or the geometry (ex. a spheres in a concave surface with a lateral load).

    There are some open points here as for example I´m also very much interested in the forces generated (strain energy, local stiffness) and an infinite thick model may not be suitable.  So I have to analyze the 2D options and prepare the model correctly.

    About comparing it with the 3D model, only with the case that has no contact (bonded). Up to now could not get any simulation finished when contact is present. The load factor goes down and down up to an insignificant increment and the simulation finished with “A fatal error has occurred”. Tricky.

    I had other models (involving contact in non-linear material) that could be simulated as 2D axisymmetric. The measures that was I interested in where nearly identical as found with a 3D model. I would always prefer a 2D model as the running time is only a fraction of the 3D model (even half 3D model). As I described it is a pity that I cannot use 2D simulation in some of the assemblies.