Skip to main content
Nov 23, 2015 1:35 PM UTC
Question

Re: Singularity on edge, trying to remove

Paul,

For this particular problem, you can add a 1mm round to all the corners, as shown below, place a measure in the highly stressed area, and plot a 1% convergence.  The attached file has no errors in the run and converges nicely.  This is just one example how you fix the run errors in the design.  You don't have to use as many elements as I did, but I just wanted to show you that you can get the model to converge in the highly stress regions and in the run summary file.

rod_model_rounds.jpg

vm_stress_global.jpg

vm_stress_rounds.jpg

vm_stress_conv.jpg

    4 replies

    Nov 26, 2015 8:05 PM UTC

     

     

    First off, thanks a bunch for the time!

     

    Uhm I should have mentioned, I'm still on Creo 2

     

    In regards to the posted plots above:

     

    I'm not sure I follow you when you say "place a measure in the highly stressed area".  I think I*'m missing the part about how to add, remove or isolate a region for analysis..  Or, how to get an analysis without the trouble-causing regions.  And that is what I assume the 3rd fringe plot is, is that you've isolated the 'fillet' to isolate the problem area, and run said convergence excluding this particular area.

     

    I have modeled up my con-rod as per what you've done, added the rounds, and I get very similar results.  But I get a convergence at 7 steps, not 5, and that it is a gradual flattening of the curve.  Mid you, I haven't modified my mesh yet..

     

    I'm still unsure about the "add measure" part, but have made a surface plot of the fillet as you've done (very cool I might add..)

     

    I will post again when I've had a few more hours to "play".

     

    thanks again.

    Dec 3, 2015 1:41 PM UTC

    Model no 1 converged at max P-level of 8, model no 2 converged at P-level of 6. I.e. more elements gives you fewer P-passes to reach specified convergence.

    Dec 3, 2015 1:58 PM UTC

    I wonder what the run-times were?