Skip to main content
Oct 14, 2014 5:56 PM UTC
Question

Re: Sheetmetal - Surface need to thicken

I made the below surface in part mode, and the Thicken Command works. I made the same in sheetmetal mode, and it didn't work. See below, as this is now activated.

sheetmetal_thicken_04.jpg

    8 replies

    Oct 14, 2014 5:58 PM UTC

    The model in the original part was made from a blend - surface. Does this not create a valid surface?

    Oct 14, 2014 6:18 PM UTC

    Seriously limited indeed. If I create the quilt in a native sheetmetal model, there is no way to thicken it directly.

    However, if the two ends are planar, the Blend feature works very well using the quilt edges.

    Pro|WorkAround^tm #1,748,298

    quilt-2-metal.PNG

    quilt-2-metal_II.PNG

    Oct 14, 2014 6:57 PM UTC

    Antonius,

    Did add thickness when you added the blend or did you make blend surfaces?

    Thanks, Dale

    Oct 14, 2014 7:27 PM UTC

    The Blend feaute became the 1st feature so it gives you a choice for the offset direction and thickness in one go, and yes, it solidified directly and recognized all the bends.

    Oct 14, 2014 6:24 PM UTC

    In sheetmetal there are different rules for what constitutes a valid solid than in non-sheetmetal.

    The main rule is that the resulting item has to be of uniform thickness.**

    If the corners of the surface are sharp, then the result of thickening is that the thickness will not be uniform. The distance from the inside of a sharp corner to the outside of the sharp corner is greater than everywhere else.

    There need to be rounds/fillets between planar sections to allow the thickness to be uniform.

    **I think the more complicated rule that drives uniform thickness rule is that for every point on the originating surface (green side) there is a point on the driven surface at the material thickness distance away and in a direction normal to the originating surface.

    Oct 14, 2014 6:31 PM UTC

    Funny thing is, David, that you can create the above Blend without converting the corners to rounds. And it does create a sheetmetal solid with sharp corners. But this is how it deals with it...

    quilt-2-metal_III.PNG

    ...And it unfolds !

    Oct 14, 2014 6:39 PM UTC

    Looks like a bug.