Skip to main content
Sep 25, 2014 12:51 PM UTC
Question

Re: shear&moment diagram

Hi Joey,

Let's start with the first problem (ex1.prt.1). Here's what I'm seeing in your post:

1. The shear-moment diagrams don't match your blue beam sketch because you ran an analysis with both ends of the beam fixed in xyz. The shear diagram shows -10 then +10, and that's what you get when you fix both ends. However, your example shows a fixed end and then a roller on the right side. To simulate a roller constraint, free the X translation and free the Z rotation.

2. The greatest moment is in the center of beam, and this would not be zero.

3. The shear-moment graphs show a beam length of 50mm, but the sketch show 5cm.

4. Modeling hint: You don't have to sketch the curves to make the beams. I made the beams point-to-point. Make all your points first, then connect the points with beams in Creo Simulate. Look at the file I uploaded as an example.

sm_01.jpg

sm_02.jpg

sm_max_prin.jpg

File uploaded.