Skip to main content
Jan 7, 2014 2:01 PM UTC
Question

Re: Problems with Singularities; New to Simulate

Hi Mark,

In your problem statement, does it clarify how the beam is supported? For example, is the LH of the beam pin supported in XYZ and the RH with a roller support but constrainted in Y? This appears to be how your beam is constrained.

beam_analysis.jpg

Figure 1: Shear Moment Diagrams

beam_analysis_const_1.jpg

Figure 2: Constraint on LH of Beam

beam_analysis_const_2.jpg

Figure 3: Constraint Near RH of Beam

One thing I noticed about your mesh, it has too many elements for the p-method. Suppress or delete the AutoGEM for element size, because this will generate over 9000 elements.

    1 reply

    Jan 7, 2014 4:14 PM UTC

    Hi Steven,

    The problem doesn't explicitly state what type of supports are present. I built this model based on the assumption of a pin support on the left side and a roller support in the mid span of the beam.

    I was hoping that by including an 'Isolate For Exclusion' AutoGEM control on the singulatity at the left side, Mechanica/Simulate would recognize this and now report stress maximums at the area of peak moment which would be 75 inches inboard from the left support (~1500 psi). However, I have tried several times but have been unsuccessful at making this happen.

    I haven't experienced any difficulties with solving with as many elements as I have included. I have never heard of an 'element limit' for use with the p-method. Could you explain this?

    Thanks.