Skip to main content
Apr 28, 2016 6:52 PM UTC
Question

Re: Panasonic Toughbook Model

Vladimir,

From Robert Lansdale: 

 

Thank you for your email. It arrived just 20mins past the end of my prior work day so let me jump to your resampling question right now.

 

I am the CTO, founder and primary system architect of Okino software over these last 30 years. I will be pleased to help you on any and all questions.

Please never hesitate to drop me questions at any time, on any topic related to 3D graphics or 3D file conversion.

 

>I would like to know if the Okino software will open a .skp (sketchup) file and export it as a .step file. 

 

No one ever converts from SketchUp to STEP or any CAD file format -- it is simply technically impossible to do. I receive this same question 3 or more  times per day since 1996.  It's always been the #1 epidemic question which I receive amongst all. You can't do this because STEP is based on pure NURBS geometry whereas SketchUp is one of the world's simplest polygonal modellers. You  can't turn meshes into a proper solids model as you expect. It is like turning water back into an ice sculpture. At most, you can only "convert" to other mesh file formats and not a CAD file format.

 

It's become an even more rampant problem since the SketchUp software became popular back in 2010, as there's 25 million people all trying to use SketchUp as a MCAD modeller (which it is not). I do explain this problem in a slightly deeper manner online here:

 

http://www.okino.com/conv/exp_sketchup.htm#reconstruction

 

At most, you'll need one of these interactive surface approximation programs.

 

They allow you to interactively re-surface a mesh model with NURBS equivalents, after which you can then attempt to stitch the NURBS back into a BREP solid. You do need a proper program to re-engineer the mesh data into proper NURBS, and then turn the NURBS into solids.

 

Now, no one ends up doing this since the average costs are in the $5k range, and you still need to spend many hours doing the reverse engineering yourself.

 

In the end, you always need to reverse engineer the mesh by resurfacing it.

 

Unfortunately there are unlimited number of YouTube videos, world-wide forum postings and $99 plug-ins from India which just pull the wool over the eyes of the unsuspecting.

 

 

1) Raindrop (RapidForm) "XOR Redesign"

 

                Mesh to NURBS (IGES and STEP) automatic resurfacing software

 

                http://www.rapidform.com/products/xor/overview/

 

 

                Requires that a user-defined curve network be put down over the

 

                high quality input mesh (as does all solutions below) in order to

 

                begin the reverse engineering process.

 

 

                Price range of US$10k to US$30k

 

 

2) "ScanTo3D" in SolidWorks Premium Edition

 

                As in all mesh to NURBS reconstruction software, this will require

 

                considerable human involvement to assign the 3D character and

 

                sketch curves to the model before it is resurfaced.

 

 

 

http://help.solidworks.com/2015/English/SolidWorks/scanto3d/c_Scanto3d_overview.htm

 

 

3) Raindrop Geomagic

 

                http://www.geomagic.com

 

 

                Product = "Geomagic Studio", price is $20,000

 

 

"The meshes are then converted to surfaces with the AutoSurface command, which "shrinkwraps" surfaces onto the polygon meshes. The software makes assumptions based on the style of surfacing you select: (1) mechanical, which applies holes, corners, and so on; or (b) organic, which emphasizes free flowing and sharp points on shapes. You can also manually convert meshes to surfaces by

 

(1) identifying features, such as extrusions, planes, lofts, sketch curves, and so on; and then (2) applying them. The surface models can be exported as 3D PDF, IGES, or STEP files."

 

 

"The Raindrop company is continually working on making the process more automatic -- from scan to CAD model without manual intervention. The goal is still some years away, but he figures that Geomagic will be first to figure it out. "

 

 

4) Geometry Systems - GSI Studio, mesh to NURBS surfaces

 

                http://www.geometrysystems.com

 

 

                GSI Studio costs approximately US$6000 for all features:

 

                         Scan data processing, mesh clean up, surfacing,

 

                                restructure mesh, color/texture processing.

 

 

                GSI Surface Studio costs approximately US$3500 per seat.

 

                It converts from mesh data to NURBS surfaces.

 

 

                The process is manual. The main task, as with all similar programs

 

                is to clean-up the mesh data: most meshes are a mess and hence

 

                need to be cleansed prior to the manual process of reverse

 

                engineering each small or large feature of the input dataset.

 

 

                On NURBS export, it can save to IGES and Rhino files,  and has

 

                limited support for STEP.

 

 

5) headus, CySlice v3 - Subdivision Surfaces

 

                http://www.headus.com.au

 

                US$4000, floating US$4600

 

                Imports OBJ, STL and PLY file formats.

 

                Exports NURBS and SubDivs to IGES and OBJ.

 

                No BREP topology info is output to IGES.

 

                Light weight meshes are automatically converted.

 

                Dense meshes require that the user draw patch boundaries first.

 

 

6) PolyWorks

 

                http://www.innovmetric.com

 

 

                Price range US$10k to US$30k per solution

 

 

7) VRmesh Reverse, US$1295.00

 

                http://www.vrmesh.com/products/reverse.asp

 

 

                For point cloud and triangle mesh processing.

 

 

                "A complete reverse engineering workflow for users to wrap point cloud

 

                 data into accurate polygon meshes as well as NURBS surfaces."

 

 

😎 SpaceClaim, US$2500 to US$3500

 

                www.spaceclaim.com

 

 

                SpaceClaim provides reverse engineering tools for mesh data.

 

 

9) McNeel's Rhino modeler has "helper plug-ins" which aid in the mesh to NURBS reconstruction process.

 

 

                http://wiki.mcneel.com/rhino/reverseengineering

 

 

                As is the norm industry wide (and little believed by many 3D users), McNeel has rightfully also disclaimed, as we do in this email, that "No one click miracles here. Once a 3D model is in mesh form, it's hard to re-create a smooth NURBS object from it. There are also a number of specialized reverse engineering software packages to partially automate this process, they range from moderately expensive to very expensive.". Their own "MeshToNurb" command does no such 3D mesh to smooth, connected NURBS conversions as often confuses many people on forums.

 

 

Regards,

 

 

Robert Lansdale, CTO & Product Manager

 

Okino Computer Graphics.

 

 

-----------------------------------------------------------

 

1515 Britannia Road East. Mississauga, Ontario. L4W 4K1.

 

Tel: 888-3D-OKINO, (905) 672-9328. http://www.okino.com