Skip to main content
Feb 16, 2016 12:39 PM UTC
Question

Re: FEA analysing the Framework extension design (Formula Student Chassis Frame).

You modeled a chassis in Creo Parametric using the Framework extension and you attempted to mesh it in Autodesk Simulation (formerly ALGOR), and I assume you tried to mesh it with h-elements.  If you have Creo Simulate integrated with Creo Parametric, I would attempt to mesh it first in Simulate.  You also have Creo Simulate Lite, as it comes standard with every Creo Paramteric.  The automesher in Creo is AutoGEM, which is geometric mapping of the elements using p-elements.  Your error code states that you don't have a watertight solid, so it sounds like you have some surfaces in your model.  Surfaces in Creo have a lavender color by default.  If you can upload the model, I'll be more than happy to examine the geometry, providing it's not a Student Version of Creo.  If it is, try uploading some screen shots.

    1 reply

    Feb 17, 2016 12:55 PM UTC

    Thanks for the answer.

    I have tried to do it on Creo Simulate... When trying to mesh, it gave me an error at a miter joint. But it seems to be right. I tried to modify the joint but it gives me the same error. Maybe a different joint technique has to be used? I tried all kind of joints with same problem. This problem seems to be everywhere a profile cut is made between 2 connecting tubes.

    I have attached the file. Please have a look.

    I have also attached images of an example of a joint where it gives me an error. The miter joint will not connect the 2 tubes together properly and when doing a profile cut for a tube connecting the miter joint it will create a small gap.

    1.png2.png

    The error on creo simulate.

    3.png