Skip to main content
Jul 6, 2015 8:27 PM UTC
Question

Re: Customer stating CREO SIMULATE does not do FEA

Richard,

GEA (Geometric Element Analysis) is the acronym RASNA used to define the adaptivity method where the fidelity of the model is increased by raising the polynomial order and the element is mapped to the geometry.  It's still the same with AutoGEM (GEM means Geometric Element Mapping).  Creo Simulate doesn't use the GEA acronym, that I know of.  That's a bold statement to say, "this is not FEA".  What are the two techniques in the rejection?  P vs H?

In principle, any problem which can be solved by the h-version can be solved by the p-version and, conversely, any problem which can be solved by the p-version can be solved by the h-version. There are large differences in convergence rates, however. For example, it was demonstrated in one well-documented plane elastic model problem that to achieve one percent relative error in energy norm (which is similar to the root-mean-square measure of error in stress), approximately 1000 degrees of freedom were needed with the p-version and properly designed mesh, whereas 10 million degrees of freedom would have been required with the h-version, utilizing 8-noded quadrilaterals and uniform mesh refinement. For details we refer to p.190 in Szabo and Babuska, Finite Element Analysis (1991).