Skip to main content
Mar 8, 2016 12:02 PM UTC
Question

Re: ANSYS - Creo Simulate discrepancy

After correcting the error in the Creo model, how long did it run before a solution was realized?

    2 replies

    Mar 8, 2016 12:15 PM UTC

    I only ran it as a quick-check, but it took about 19 minutes, to be compared with about 7 minutes with 1 contact + 2 bonded interfaces+quick check. So the 2+ hours it took for the model with SPA+one contact+2 bonded interfaces should be expected to take considerably more than 2 hours with 3 contacts + SPA. SPA is not good for non-linear it seems. My advice is to run quick-check + fine mesh. Not "Creo-kosher" but what do you do...?


    Jul 15, 2016 4:12 PM UTC

    Quick check is not "that bad" really. It sets each element to P=3 so in theory is better than using linear or quadratic tets.... assuming the mesh is not too rough.

    *with quick check you are forcing Simulate to act like a traditional h-code, so results will be *very* mesh-dependent (just like Nastran, Ansys, Abaqus...)