Skip to main content
Sep 24, 2015 6:50 PM UTC
Question

How Many Votes Does It Take?

These questions are specifically directed to the PTC Community Help and the managerial oversight for Product Ideas.

1.  How many votes does it take to get a Product Idea considered for future developement?

2.  How many votes does it take to get a Product Idea implemented into the software?

    43 replies

    Sep 24, 2015 8:19 PM UTC

    I'm just another community member, but based on past experience, the answer to both questions is the same.  The number doesn't really matter.  Consideration and implementation of ideas seems to be purely at the discretion of the different product managers.  We've seen ideas with only 1 vote get consideration while the idea with the most votes ever (290) has never even been commented on by anyone from PTC.

    What really seems to happen, is if someone suggests something that a product manager thinks is a good idea and can be implemented without too much difficulty, it get's considered and possibly implemented.  On the other hand, if something is requested that the product manager doesn't care for, or doesn't want to commit (potentially significant) resources to implement, then it seems to just languish forever.

    There doesn't seem to be any accountability or broad commitment from management to actually do something with ideas once they cross a certain threshold.  It would go a long way for someone from management to at least respond to the ideas.  If the idea is bad, say so!  If there is a better approach, say so!  Don't just let the ideas sit out there forever with no response.

    By the way, here is a summary of the ideas right now:

    • Open For Voting:  4871
    • For Future Consideration:  51
    • Implementation In Progress:  15
    • No Plans To Implement:  41
    • Under Consideration:  19
    • Current Functionality:  101
    1-Visitor
    Sep 24, 2015 8:43 PM UTC

    Tom,

    for the first idea I remember a song from the past called "Lucky Man" (Emerson, Lake & Palmer)

    Sep 24, 2015 8:43 PM UTC

    I'm not sure I'd mark that as the correct response.  Notice my first sentence:

    I'm just another community member...

    Sep 24, 2015 8:47 PM UTC

    I think it's pretty much the correct answer. Give or take.

    Sep 24, 2015 9:20 PM UTC

    Let's try pinging a few of the managers and see if we can get an official response from their different groups...

    Brian Thompson‌

    Walid Saad‌

    Darryn Kozak‌

    Don Breda‌

    Mark Williford‌

    Michael Prudhomme‌

    Devi Vijayakumar‌

    Marc Schuetz‌

    Jim Barrett-Smith‌

    Sep 25, 2015 2:51 AM UTC

    Tom,

    There are a few PMs you're missing, perhaps.  One of the most active in the Windchill space would be Jeffrey Zemsky‌‌.  He's got to be sick of me tagging him by now...?? 

    Anyway, I'm responding because this is the perfect opportunity.  And also because I am frustrated with the large amount of community members who are "in the dark" about something that is "in the works".

    First, I will say that I am a PTC Technical Committee member.  If you're not familar with TCs, you can inquire on the ptcuser.org website.  One of the many TC topics is the Product Ideas.  The Product Ideas are not the only source for Windchill R/D.  And as Tom's numbers have shown, the number of Ideas is outrageous.  There is a ton of junk and duplication in those numbers.  We can't expect PTC to run through these all.

    Therefore, in the TCs, we are working on a pilot program to bring some organization movement to the Ideas.  I'm sure PMs will continue to monitor Ideas and if something new pops up that they can answer right away (like they arlready have plans to implement it in the next release - marking it as "implementation in progress", or if they remember some similar idea, marking it as "duplicate").  But for some of the more original Ideas, such as the checkin comment one that is getting a lot of discussion right now, the following process would apply...

    Basically, a TC member must pick up the idea and gather use cases.  Votes don't mean much.  The use cases are the key.  And also, on the back end, PTC can see the company of the users who vote on an idea.  So getting 10 people from your company to vote up an idea will not help.  (I was a cheeky violator of that.)

    After the TC member gathers the information, the TC member works with a PTC PM to get the idea implemented into the software.  There is much more detail behind the process than that.  But I don't want to describe the details at this point since it is still pilot process.

    Now you might be thinking... "okay, how do I get in touch with a TC member to get my Idea sponsored?"  Unfortunately, we don't really have a good way for that right now, as details still need to be worked out.  But I would appreciate your feedback if you're not a TC member.  One thing that has been mentioned by Ryan Kelley is for TC members, or at least the TC members who will be sponsoring Ideas, to have special badges in the community, similar to Tom and Steven that identify them as Community Champions.  Personally, I prefer something like a published list perhaps.  And with each of the TC names, an area of the software they are most-likely to sponsor.

    I hope you find this information useful.  And I hope it receives a lot of visibility.  Tom, Steven, Marco...I rely on you and others as Community Champions and power users to help with this message.  I look forward to hearing back from the Community about this pilot Product Idea process.

    Tagging some people here...

    Jennifer Reding‌June Dolan‌Ryan Kelley‌

    1-Visitor
    Sep 25, 2015 12:44 PM UTC

    Ben Perry‌,

    be sure I will share your comment whenever I'll see some user asking information on how Product Idea works.

    Sep 29, 2015 7:53 PM UTC

    I was wondering about this as well.  I'm having a hard time believing that a request from one of the big showcase companies with 50,000+ users is going to have the same weight as one from a small company with only 5 users.  I have to believe that if one of these large companies got 20,000 of their users to vote up a product idea, someone would respond, even if the idea was only being requested by that one company.

    I just took a quick look and there seems to be very poor correlation between the size of a company and the number of users each company has participating in the community.  (These are displayed on the 'People' page.)

    companies.PNG

    Giving each company only one vote seems unfair to the large companies, but giving each user one vote seems like it would make it difficult for small companies to have any real impact on the priorities.  I tend to be the point of contact between our company and PTC, so we will probably never have more than one vote on any particular idea, even if everyone in the company wants it.

    Sep 29, 2015 9:07 PM UTC

    Perhaps I have not spoken clearly.  You'll have to use common sense here.  I'm not saying 1 vote per company.  I'm saying if a product idea exists with 20 positive votes, and 18 are from 18 users in the same company, that will throw a flag.  I'm not saying that the idea will be tracked as 3 positive votes.  I'm only saying that the use cases will need to be strong.

    In the end, it is strong use cases, and the identification of something to move the product forward, are what will make for a solid product idea.  Does it make sense, generally?

    Sep 29, 2015 9:24 PM UTC

    Yes, but... these are "Product Ideas", not "Product Use Cases".  If only the ideas that have corresponding use cases are really going to be considered, somehow that needs to be communicated to everyone before they create a new idea.

    On a slightly different note, ‌ wrote this a few days back:

    One PTC employee told be directly that the Product Idea system is broken, and another PTC employee told me just a few days ago that the Product Managers point their fingers at one another and say, "that's not my area", and the Product Idea doesn't get assigned to anyone, and then it just is shoved into a cyberspace corner and forgotten.

    If this really is the case, should we re-align the PTC community structure to agree with how PTC divides up product management?  If not, should we add some additional criteria (drop downs) to the product idea creation process so that they get routed to the right product manager?  Maybe something similar to how tech support cases are created?

    I hope I don't sound like a broken record here, but someone needs to be responsible to clean up the product ideas on a regular basis.  I really don't care if it's the PTC product manager or some other designated person, the "Open For Voting" to "Any Other Status" ratio has got to come down or people will continue to feel like no one is listening and PTC doesn't really care.  Taking a few key ideas and building use cases for them isn't going to cut it.

    Oct 20, 2015 8:18 PM UTC

    This is an interesting thread. As a non-Product Manager, I'd note a few things:

    • A lot of the "Open for Voting" product ideas are either current functionality, in work, or will be included in the future. For example, the highest scoring product idea Remove all java applets in Windchill is "Open for Voting" - but it is definitely something we've been working on over the course of multiple releases. So I agree product ideas need to be cleaned up.
    • However, the ability to update the status of product ideas is limited to certain users (I'm not sure who - maybe can clarify). So while there are a lot of PTC employees reading the PTC Community discussions, it doesn't mean we can all work on cleaning up or updating the product ideas.

    • PTC Community is a public forum and we can't always talk explicitly about what's coming.  For example, there was a thread recently about Windchill 11 changes, and while I would have loved to just post a massive list of what we've got planned (because I'm excited about the work my dev teams did!) - I was cautioned not to. That said, when I see ideas or discussions on specific things I know we have plans to implement, I try to comment.
      Occasionally, there are some ideas/enhancements that I've seen in our queues, but which haven't been assigned to a release yet. I'm not sure if it's helpful or annoying to comment, "Oh yeah, we'll do that....some day."
    • I've got some down time right now. I'll see if I can create a few lists of product ideas related to the dev teams I work with (documents/DTI, search, workflow, ProjectLink, PartsLink, life cycles) and forward them along to the PMs.
    Oct 21, 2015 6:39 AM UTC

    You say "A lot of the "Open for Voting" product ideas are either current functionality, in work, or will be included in the future. "
    If you look into the product ideas you'll see that most of the product ideas are not worked on.

    A product idea that is not voted or commented does not mean that it is a thing that shouldn't be fixed or at least commented by ptc.

    From all of my product ideas only one was commented by a PTC guy. This ist more than disappointing if i compare this to the behavior of other companies.  Apart from that all the other ideas which are not only ideas but als things that are needed for the daily use are wasted in this database.


    Regards

    Herbert Linseisen

    Oct 21, 2015 7:45 PM UTC

    I think I phrased that poorly - I just mean that there are more product ideas that are current functionality than is currently reflected in the status, but I shouldn't have implied that the majority of product ideas have been implemented.

    From all of my product ideas only one was commented by a PTC guy. This ist more than disappointing if i compare this to the behavior of other companies.  Apart from that all the other ideas which are not only ideas but als things that are needed for the daily use are wasted in this database

    Personally, I'd like to see more PTC people active on here - last spring I even gave a short presentation to my team about PTC Community to encourage them to participate. For what it's worth, I also believe a lot more PTC people read discussions through email subscriptions and forward threads. And now that forum discussions are included in our knowledge base search results, PTC Community has even more visibility and value.

    As an example of this, I got an email last night from our Director of GPD Solutions, who is/was following the discussion through his email subscription. A couple weeks ago some PMs and Solution Managers met to discuss a strategy on responding to Product Ideas. I don't know what the strategy is going to be, but I guess I just wanted to add some reassurance that the ideas and information shared here is 1) valued and 2) a work in progress.