Skip to main content
Jun 24, 2016 8:00 AM UTC
Question

FEA - Would like the Max value to be identified on a Model (13133779)

Using Creo Elements\Direct Design Advisor, I would like the Max Value to be identifiable on a model, by another means other that the contour colour - i.e maybe a Vertex, as per the "Centroid" (C of G) function on the 'Measure Part' Menu.

When working on an assy, or busy model, the highest value may be difficult to initially see, or in a potentially unexpected area.

Details from PTC call:

https://support.ptc.com/appserver/cs/view/solution.jsp?n=CS240433

4 replies

Jun 24, 2016 9:52 PM UTC

Hi Steven,

I can see what the values are (& the colour associated to the colour), but I would like to know if there is a function on modelling that will highlight where on the model this value is.  In the images, one is a simple analysis with contour map and part, and the other is the Part Measure function, where the Centroid (x,y,z co-ord) is highlighted with a Vertex

FEA Image

FEA-MinMax.JPG

Centroid Vertex:

Centroid.JPG

It's by no means a showstopper, but would help with some of the more busier models.

I would like the option in FEA to be able highlight the 'Highest' value from the Contour map (or maybe even any value in the contour map range - if this is at all possible) to a 3D co-ord on the Model.  In a similar way to how the Centroid is highlighted with a Vertex above.

Jun 27, 2016 8:13 AM UTC

Hi Steve, yes, it's a fairly entry level based FEA (especially compared with Simulate), & is very easy to pick up and put down.  You don't have to be a dedicated FE Analyst to use the functions.  It uses the MSC Nastran engine and is completely integrated with in the Creo Elements\Direct modeler, so there's only one source of data (model).

Creo Elements/Direct Finite Element Analysis | PTC

I think the displaying of Max, and or a Max-Min defined range is not an unreasonable request/expectation.

Jun 27, 2016 9:28 AM UTC

What does mean, in FEA, the MAX value in a vertex?

I find more realistic, stresses and strains on some areas. Usually I use contour with option Min-Max, specifying a narrow range of stresses. For example, when FEA answer me back MIN 2.83MPa and MAX 26.94Mpa, I use Contour Option with [Range Math] "Min-Max" and [Min]: 25.0, [Max]: 27.0 and [No. Colors]: 2 so that I locate easily where the max stress is. You could narrow the contour min max to reach a small mount of area reduced to some vertex. But what does this mean?

Jun 27, 2016 9:34 AM UTC

Hi Louis, nice to hear from you!

You've hit the nail on the head.  The Min-Max range definitions is the method we are using now (narrow down the range to the very highest values), but it was a query raised to me by a customer.

Whatever the highest value is, it must the result of a calculation on a Node, and the customer wanted to know if we could highlight this 'node' or point.

Does not necessarily have to be a Vertex Point - but as that is the option used when defining a centroid, it seemed an appropriate suggestion.