Skip to main content
Sep 12, 2013 12:13 PM UTC
Solved

Creo Simulate 2.0 - Modal & Dynamic Frequency Analyses

Will Creo Simulate perform the following analyses on a rotor turbine?

 

1.  In order to perform a dynamic frequency, a modal analysis must be performed first.

 

2.  After the modal analysis, spin the model at 96000 rpm for 1 minute at 75 degrees F.

 

3.  View the stresses.

 

Currently, PTC technical support has not been able to answer this, as the case number 11575905 was started on Sept 5, 2013.  The online knowledge base has only one example, which doesn't fully address the problem at hand.  Any comments/solutions are welcomed.

 

 

 

 

ehaenenAnswer
Sep 3, 2015 12:55 PM UTC

 

I've been doing quite a lot of dynamic analysis, using creo, and am happy with what it does.

It should be able to do the things you ask, however: it is an uinlikely dynamics problem.

The time response is a response to a preferably dynamic excitation. just spinning a rotor (assuming it is mass-balanced) is not a dynamic event in that sense. You could easily get very good results using centrifugal load (a static analysis). I use the dynamic analysis to determine critical frequency (a modal analysis).

one could investigate the response of the rotor to a spinning up, or a sudden stop. But as said, rotating it for a minute is a static load. A good time response (meaning you use enough modes) should resemble the results for a centrifugal load-static.

 

Does this help?

Kind regards

Erik

5 replies

ehaenenAnswer
Sep 3, 2015 12:55 PM UTC

 

I've been doing quite a lot of dynamic analysis, using creo, and am happy with what it does.

It should be able to do the things you ask, however: it is an uinlikely dynamics problem.

The time response is a response to a preferably dynamic excitation. just spinning a rotor (assuming it is mass-balanced) is not a dynamic event in that sense. You could easily get very good results using centrifugal load (a static analysis). I use the dynamic analysis to determine critical frequency (a modal analysis).

one could investigate the response of the rotor to a spinning up, or a sudden stop. But as said, rotating it for a minute is a static load. A good time response (meaning you use enough modes) should resemble the results for a centrifugal load-static.

 

Does this help?

Kind regards

Erik

Sep 7, 2015 8:52 AM UTC

Is there something wrong with the dating of posts? According to the header, this post was made September 3rd 2015, i.e. quite recently, according to Mr Dunker, it's an old post...?

Sep 10, 2015 2:55 PM UTC

‌I believe what happened is that the post date was updated when we migrated this discussion from the former "Creo Simulation" group to the Analysis and Simulation‌ product sub-space.

Sep 10, 2015 4:51 PM UTC

Strange hypothesis, have you been migrating this as late as september 2? Steven's post was on the top of the list of simulate items that day. I wouldn't have answered it if it was dated further back.