Skip to main content
Jul 8, 2014 11:54 AM UTC
Solved

Creo 3.0 Unite Technology

Creo 3.0 claims that it can open SolidWorks, CATIA, and NX files directly, without the need for additional software.

  • Does this mean it will open the modeling history of these files too?
  • Has anyone seen this demonstrated?

 

 

 

 

    Jul 8, 2014 1:14 PM UTC

     

    you are very optimistic . I am almost sure that you cannot see modeling history of foreign models in Part mode in Creo Parametric 3.0. PTC Creo Unite technology is related to Assembly mode, only. Maybe this technology will replace older Import&ATB technology.

     

    Martin Hanak

     

    6 replies

    Jul 8, 2014 1:14 PM UTC

     

    you are very optimistic . I am almost sure that you cannot see modeling history of foreign models in Part mode in Creo Parametric 3.0. PTC Creo Unite technology is related to Assembly mode, only. Maybe this technology will replace older Import&ATB technology.

     

    Martin Hanak

     

    Jul 8, 2014 1:41 PM UTC

    i think in later maintenance releases M030 you would be able to save the files as solidworks,inventor catia...files also.

    modelling history....nope..not at present.

    solidworks does open proe files with modelling history..it is good with simple models but as expected fails when it encounters complex geometry.

    the sketches reman unconstarined though..and oh yes..it is converted into a solidworks file.

    Jul 8, 2014 4:47 PM UTC

    Isnt this more legal problem then tehnical? You can open other formats as dumb geometry or convert to yours with some things recognised but being able to see features and evrything and still keep it as original format is a bit copyright issue in my view. Maybe if PTC drops ton of cash to competitors for them to allow this.

    But being able to incorporate other formats in assembly without convert and that they update is a big plus anyway.

    Jul 8, 2014 5:07 PM UTC

    if PTC develops its own technology to read the model tree history of its competitor files then i do not think it would be a copyright issue.

    flexible modeling extension is coming up pretty good.....that i bieleve would be able to solve many problems with handling geometry of PTC creo competitors!

    Jul 9, 2014 12:09 PM UTC

    Point was to use other formats not having to convert them to Creo not to see model tree.

    I thought that making flexibile changes on lets say Catia file and then saving it then you can open it in Catia and have all features intact with added something to represent those flexibile changes. So "colaboration" can realy happen.

    As it seems its still one way street but without conversion.

    Jul 9, 2014 12:14 PM UTC

    i think PTC developed the FMX for this reason only, to be able to edit features without history tree for non-native files also.

    i think the FMX would get better with new releases and we might just not need the history tree at all for non-native files for editing.

    there are many new features...which our interesting...

    1. show failed references

    2. untrim surface.

    3. improved flatten quilt feature..this is good feature in Creo.

    4. nice enhancements in sheetmetal.

    5. new way of inserting notes in drawings

    6. reorder with option to reorder children.

    the best would offcourse would be....least number of bugs!