Skip to main content
Apr 22, 2013 12:51 PM UTC
Question

Creating and Manipulating Meshes - PTC Online Tutorial

I reviewed the online tutorial by Mark Taddonio, and it was well worth the time to view it. However, there is one thing that should be brought to the audience, and that is no matter how many elements were used, the peak stresses didn't vary that much. There were three runs in the tutorial with the following results:

1. 81.3 MPa

2. 80.9 MPa

3. 82.5 MPa

And no matter how many elements are used, the results should always be verified with a convergence plot on the solution. Also, if the intent is to reduce the number of elements, this model has symmetry, and it could have been cut in half lenghtwise.

In conclusion, more p-elements doesn't necessairly mean a more accurate solution. But the video does show how to create and manipulate meshes.

    2 replies

    May 1, 2013 6:39 PM UTC
    you are correct that all three runs with the different meshes result in nearly the same value for the maximum stress. That's because Creo Simulate is based on the p-version of the finite element method, in which the fidelity of the finite element model is increased by raising the polynomial orders of the finite element basis functions. This approach is in contrast to traditional h-version finite element programs, in which the fidelity of the model is increased by adding additional elements. Also, Creo Simulate has convergence algorithms that automatically increase the polynomial orders so that accurate solutions are efficiently found without requiring manual intervention from the user. The efficacy of this approach is the reason why the same result was obtained for all three meshes.

    Unfortunately, the person who made the demo was new to PTC, did not fully understand these points and made a few confusing statements. Therefore, even though the demo correctly demonstrated how to use AutoGEM controls to influence the mesh, PTC decided to remove the demo until we create a new one that is less confusing.

    Thanks for your feedback.
    Jul 27, 2015 3:57 PM UTC

    Hello Mr. Steven and Mr. Lawrence

    Could you say me how create P-Elements for mesh?

    I'm with assembly project and applied Mapped mesh but is very hard work.

    I have been commented the possibility of P-element mesh... Is better for reduce time.

    Thanks for all.

    BR

    Gorka Garcia

    Integral PLM Experts